Case Based Reasoning for Customizing Treatment Processes

Case Based Reasoning for Customizing Treatment Processes

Carolin Kaiser (University of Erlangen-Nuremberg, Germany)
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60566-002-8.ch024
OnDemand PDF Download:


This chapter introduces a case based reasoning (CBR) system for customizing treatment processes. The CBR system enables the generating of inpatient and outpatient treatment processes and the supporting of e-services in heath care networks individually customized to the patients’ needs. According to the CBR paradigm, which solves problems based on past experience, the proposed system uses old treatment processes of similar former patients and modifies them for new patients. In general, CBR is an established and well suited artificial intelligence method to support medical decision making. However, CBR systems capable of planning treatment processes by adapting old treatment processes to fit new patients are rare. The aim of this system is to increase the treatment quality of the patient by providing physicians with valuable treatment propositions and to contribute to the development of medical CBR Systems by introducing procedures enabling the generating of new treatment processes by modifying former treatment processes.
Chapter Preview


In the age of a growing flood of information on medical data and knowledge, medical decision support systems are becoming more and more important. Various artificial intelligence methods have been implemented in numerous systems to support the medical reasoning process. Among these methods case based reasoning (CBR) was established to support medical decision making. CBR (Amodt & Placa, 1994) solves problems by using past experiences and general knowledge. Past experiences are saved in form of cases in the case base. For solving a new arising problem the CBR system searches for similar problems and attempts to adapt their solutions to fit the new problem. CBR is particularly suited for helping find solutions to medical problems (Heinisch et al., 1998, p. 1) as it resembles the physicians’ cognitive process of recalling former patients and reusing past experiences. Furthermore, the collection of patient records which represent a valuable knowledge resource can easily be integrated in a CBR system as a case base.

Medical CBR systems can be divided into different categories depending on their purpose-oriented properties and their functional properties. Purpose-oriented properties (Nilsson & Sollenborn, 2004, p. 179) describe the general aim which the system fulfills and allow the separation of medical CBR systems into diagnostic systems, classification systems, tutoring systems and planning systems. While diagnostic systems are intended to support the whole diagnostic process, classification systems focus on special diagnostic problems (e.g. image classification). Tutoring systems aim at teaching students medical knowledge based on patient records. Planning systems provide assistance by configuring medical processes (e.g. therapies) consisting of several steps. Considering the functional properties CBR systems can be classified into case-match-systems and case-adaptation-systems (Goos, 1996, p. 15). Case-match-systems only enable the retrievement of similar patient cases, whereas case-adaptation-systems also allow the adaptation of past cases to fit new patients. Most of the medical CBR systems developed in the last years are classification systems or diagnostic systems and they support case-matching only (Nilsson & Sollenborn 2004, p. 182). Moreover, the majority of these systems focus on inpatient treatment and specialize in one certain disease. Planning systems which realize the adaptation task, which support inpatient and outpatient treatment processes in health care networks and which implement disease independent algorithms are missing.

This chapter describes such a CBR system. The system proposes inpatient and outpatient treatment processes in health care networks based on the adaptation of treatment processes to new patients and can be applied to the treatment of various diseases. Besides the treatment steps to be fulfilled by the physicians, the generated propositions also contain e-services to satisfy the coordination and informational needs of the health care providers and the patients.

In order to clarify the functionality of this appraoch, all functions of the CBR systems are illustrated by example of heart failure treatment. Heart failure is a syndrome which is caused by cardiac disorder and which weakens the pumping capability of the heart supplying the tissue with blood and oxygen (Hoppe & Erdmann, 2004, p. 11). It is one of the most frequent and severest diseases of the industrialized countries with an approximate prevalence ranging from 0.3% to 2% and an estimated incidence of 0.1% to 0.5% (Cowie et al., 1997, p. 211). The medical treatment of the multitude of patients is important. However, in practice many patients do not obtain an adequate therapie compliant to actual guidelines (Hoppe & Erdmann, 2004, p. 15; Stödter, 2000, pp. 6, 18f). So the application of the Medical CBR system to the treatment of heart failure will hopefully contribute to the improvement of this situation.

Key Terms in this Chapter

Maintenance: Preservation and recoverage of the Case Based Reasoning System. The aim of the maintenance is to garantuee high quality and high efficiency of the Case Based Reasoning System throughout its whole life-cycle (Wilson, 2001, p. 1). The tasks of the maintenance are monitoring the status of the Case Based Reasoning System in order to recognize changes, which decrease the capability of the Case Based Reasoning System, and executing counteractive measures.

Medical Case Based Reasoning: Case based reasoning for supporting medical decision making. Medical Case Based Reasoning Systems can be applied to different medical purposes. They are often used in diagnosis and classification (Nilsson & Sollenborn 2004, p. 182). Further fields of application are tutoring and planning therapies.

Case Based Reasoning: Method of Artificial Intelligence. It enables the solving of problems based on experience (Goos, 1996, S. 13). The experience is saved in the form of cases in a case base. Each case consists of two part: a decription of the problem and a description of its solution. In order to solve a new problem, Case Based Reasoning searches for the case of the case base which is most similar to the new problem and reuses its solution.

Structural Adaptation: Adaptation approach of Case Based Reasoning. It allows adapting the structure of the solution of a case from the case base in order to fit the problem of the query. Depending on the differences of the problem of the query and the problem of the similar case from the case base, components of the solution of the similar case are removed and reordered or new components are added (Wilke & Bergmann 1998, p. 500).

Extented K-D-Tree: Approach to save and retrieve knowledge in an efficient way. The basic idea is to partiton the knowledge base into k dimensions using a tree consisting of nodes and edges (Weß, 1995, pp. 180ff). While the leaf nodes of the tree save the knowledge, the inner nodes and the edges contain testing conditions, which direct the search of the knowledge. In Case Based Reasoning it can be used to save and search for cases efficiently.

Similarity Measures: Two-digit, real-valued function on the problem space: Sim: PxP ? [0;1]. The value range of similarity measures is restricted to the interval between zero and one, whereas the value zero represents minimal similarity and the value one symbolizes maximal similarity. Similarity measures enable the calculation of similarity between the problem of the query and the problem of the case of the case base (Stahl 2003, S. 47).

Gradient Descent Method: Method for searching a local minimum of a function. In order to find a local minimum, the algorithm moves in the direction of the negative gradient (vector of the partial differentiations) of the function. In Case Based Reasoning it can be used to optimize the global similarity measure according to the preferences of the user (Stahl, 2003, pp. 105ff). For this purporse an error function must be defined by comparing the order of the cases preferred by the user and the order calculated by the global similarity measure. The gradient descent method searches the minimum of this error function.

Object-Oriented Representation: Format to represent knowledge. In comparision to Attribute-Value-Vectors it provides better posibilities of representing structural knowledge. In this type of representation knowledge is characterised by classes. A concrete piece of knowledge is composed of a set of instances of these classes.

Attribute-Value-Vectors: Format to represent knowledge. It is often used to represent case knowledge in Case Based Reasoning (Richter, 2003, p. 412). The knowledge is characterised by a certain number n of attributes A1,A2,...,An. One concrete piece of knowledge P is specified by the vector of the attribute values a1,a2,...,an from the ranges R1,R2,...,Rn: P = (a1,a2,...,an) ? R1xR2x...xRn.

Complete Chapter List

Search this Book:
Editorial Advisory Board
Table of Contents
Athina A. Lazakidou
Athina A. Lazakidou
Chapter 1
Sanjay P. Sood, Sandhya Keeroo, Victor W.A. Mbarika, Nupur Prakash, Ankur Seth
It is claimed that seeds of ‘medical informatics’ were sown in 1960s.From this time until the 1990s experts have described the discipline as... Sample PDF
Medical Informatics: Thirty Six Peer-Reviewed Shades
Chapter 2
D. John Doyle
E-health technology has started to become commonplace in the clinical world, with practitioners setting up their own Web sites to disseminate... Sample PDF
Medical Privacy and the Internet
Chapter 3
Ana Ferreira, Ricardo Cruz-Correia, Luís Antunes, David Chadwick
This chapter reports the authors’ experiences regarding security of the electronic medical record (EMR). Although the EMR objectives are to support... Sample PDF
Security of Electronic Medical Records
Chapter 4
György Surján
This chapter outlines the history of medical classifications in a general cultural context. Classification is a general phenomenon in science and... Sample PDF
The Cultural History of Medical Classifications
Chapter 5
Spyros Kitsiou
A fundamental requirement for achieving continuity of care is commonly accepted to be the integration and interoperability of different clinical... Sample PDF
Overview and Analysis of Electronic Health Record Standards
Chapter 6
Graham D. Bodie, Mohan J. Dutta, Ambar Basu
This chapter overviews an integrative model of e-health use that connects social disparities at the population level with individual characteristics... Sample PDF
The Integrative Model of E-Health Use
Chapter 7
Firat Kart
In this chapter we describe a distributed e-healthcare system that uses service oriented architecture as a basis for designing, implementing... Sample PDF
A Distributed E-Healthcare System
Chapter 8
Davor Mucic
In this chapter the author gives the short review over wide range of telepsychiatry applications. Furthermore, describes completely new and... Sample PDF
Telepsychiatry Within European E-Health
Chapter 9
Azizah Omar
In this chapter the author discusses several marketing principles and issues related to pitfalls and successes of Telehealth application in the case... Sample PDF
Pitfalls and Successes of a Web-Based Wellness Program
Chapter 10
Isabel de la Torre Díez
This chapter describes a Web -based application to store and exchange Electronic Health Records (EHR) and medical images in Ophthalmology... Sample PDF
A Web-Based Application to Exchange Electronic Health Records and Medical Images in Ophthalmology
Chapter 11
Mario Ceresa
This chapter mainly focuses on biomedical knowledge representation and its use in biomedicine. It first illustrates the existent more relevant... Sample PDF
Clinical and Biomolecular Ontologies for E-Health
Chapter 12
Roger Tait, Gerald Schaefer
The registration of corresponding patient volumes is often a pre-requisite for medical imaging tasks. Accurate alignment, however, usually results... Sample PDF
Distributed Medical Volume Registration
Chapter 13
Bill Ag. Drougas
Internet today is one of the most useful tools for information, education and business or entertainment. It is one of the modern technology tools... Sample PDF
Electronic Commerce for Health Products Services-Problems- Quality and Future
Chapter 14
Christos Bountis
This chapter introduces and reviews the concept of distributed knowledge management within the Healthcare environment and between Healthcare and... Sample PDF
Distributed Knowledge Management in Healthcare
Chapter 15
Jelena Vucetic
This paper describes business and technological challenges and solutions for a successful emergency telemedicine venture called MediComm. Its... Sample PDF
An Analysis of a Successful Emergency Telemedicine Venture
Chapter 16
Tammara Massey, Foad Dabiri, Roozbeh Jafari, Hyduke Noshadi, Philip Brisk, Majid Sarrafzadeh
This chapter introduces reconfigurable design techniques for light-weight medical systems. The research presented in this chapter demonstrates how... Sample PDF
Reconfigurable Embedded Medical Systems
Chapter 17
Konstantinos Perakis
The evolutions in the field of telecommunications technologies, with the robustness and the fidelity these new systems provide, have significantly... Sample PDF
Third Generation (3G) Cellular Networks in Telemedicine: Technological Overview, Applications, and Limitations
Chapter 18
Anton V. Vladzymyrskyy
This chapter introduces usage of telemedicine consultations in daily clinical practice. Author has describe process of teleconsultation, sample... Sample PDF
Telemedicine Consultations in Daily Clinical Practice: Systems, Organisation, Efficiency
Chapter 19
Cheon-Pyo Lee, J. P. Shim
Ubiquitous healthcare has become possible with rapid advances in information and communication technologies. Ubiquitous healthcare will bring about... Sample PDF
Ubiquitous Healthcare: Radio Frequency Identification (RFID) in Hospitals
Chapter 20
Rafael Capilla, Alfonso del Río, Miguel Ángel Valero, José Antonio Sánchez
This chapter deals with the conceptualization, design and implementation of an m-health solution to support ubiquitous, integrated and continuous... Sample PDF
Agile Patient Care with Distributed M-Health Applications
Chapter 21
Žilbert Tafa
This chapter describes the very actual issues on mobile health (M-H) and home care (H-C) telecare systems, reviewing state of the art as well as... Sample PDF
Mobile Health Applications and New Home Care Telecare Systems: Critical Engineering Issues
Chapter 22
José Antonio Seoane Fernández, Juan Luis Pérez Ordóñez, Noha Veiguela Blanco
This chapter presents an architecture for the integration of various algorithms for digital image processing (DIP) into web-based information... Sample PDF
A New System for the Integration of Medical Imaging Processing Algorithms into a Web Environment
Chapter 23
Daniel Welfer
This chapter discusses the concept of open-source picture archiving and communication systems (i.e. PACS), which are low cost, and easy to... Sample PDF
PACS Based on Open-Source Software Components
Chapter 24
Carolin Kaiser
This chapter introduces a case based reasoning (CBR) system for customizing treatment processes. The CBR system enables the generating of inpatient... Sample PDF
Case Based Reasoning for Customizing Treatment Processes
Chapter 25
I. Apostolakis, A. Chryssanthou, I. Varlamis
A significant issue in health related applications is protecting a patient’s profile data from unauthorized access. In the case of telemedicine... Sample PDF
A Holistic Perspective of Security in Health Related Virtual Communities
Chapter 26
Stamatia Ilioudi
This chapter aims to present various virtual learning environments for medical purposes in the world. More than ever, medical students and... Sample PDF
Virtual Learning Environments in Health
Chapter 27
Jelena Vucetic
In the last decade, advances in medicine, telemedicine, computer technologies, information systems, Web applications, robotics and... Sample PDF
Multimedia Distance Learning Solutions for Surgery
Chapter 28
Maria Andréia F. Rodrigues
This chapter shows how recent computing technologies such as collaborative virtual environments, high speed networks and mobile devices can be used... Sample PDF
Collaborative Virtual Environments and Multimedia Communication Technologies in Healthcare
Chapter 29
Tiffany A. Koszalka, Bradley Olson
A major issue facing medical education training programs across the USA is the recent advent of universal mandatory duty hour limitations and the... Sample PDF
Transforming a Pediatrics Lecture Series to Online Instruction
Chapter 30
Anastasia N. Kastania, Stelios Zimeras
In this chapter the authors investigate telehealth quality and reliability assurance. Various models and standards can be applied to assess software... Sample PDF
Quality and Reliability Aspects in Telehealth Systems
Chapter 31
Kleopatra Alamantariotou
Recent statistics show that the World Wide Web has now grown to over 100 million sites: a phenomenal expansion in only 15 years (Mulligan 2007). It... Sample PDF
Quality of Health Information on the Internet
Chapter 32
Kashif Hussain
This chapter provides a practical approach to computerized system validation (CSV) for the pharmaceutical organizations for the users dealing with... Sample PDF
A Practical Approach to Computerized System Validation
Chapter 33
Bill Ag Drougas, Maria Sevdali
Ergophysiology as a division of the Physiology and helps us today to understand what happens in the human body and movement and how we are able to... Sample PDF
Organization and Evaluation of Experimental Measurements of Ergophysiological Data with the Method of SF12V2
Chapter 34
Daniele Apiletti
Current advances in sensing devices and wireless technologies are providing a high opportunity for improving care quality and reducing the medical... Sample PDF
Ubiquitous Risk Analysis of Physiological Data
Chapter 35
Manfred Doepp
In our energy diagnostic department we noticed more and more cases with irrational stimulus-reaction- patterns and with a chaotic regulation state... Sample PDF
Chaotization of Human Systems by Technical Electromagnetic Fields
Chapter 36
Mary Schmeida, Ramona McNeal
This chapter is an analysis of demographic variables influencing policy outcomes with online health information searches in the general U.S. public.... Sample PDF
Demographic Differences in Telehealth Policy Outcomes
About the Contributors