The Clinical Information System: A Case of Misleading Design Decisions

The Clinical Information System: A Case of Misleading Design Decisions

Gurpreet Dhillon (Cranfield School of Management, United Kingdom)
Copyright: © 2006 |Pages: 15
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-59904-396-0.ch021
OnDemand PDF Download:


The case study described in this chapter concerns the introduction of a new computer based integrated Clinical Information System (CIS) into a British National Health Services Trust-the Sunrise Trust. At the time of the study most of the system modules had been developed and were being tested largely for technical aspects. The system was being introduced during a period when the organization was experiencing significant changes. It was an environment where new structures were being created and the existing ones changed. Indeed, the case study was selected primarily because of these factors. The analysis of these structures, formal and informal, provides insight into the management of information systems. Various stakeholders in the Hospital Trust felt that a computer based information system would facilitate the change process. However the analysis and design of the system posed its own problems. The system turned out to be inflexible with respect to the core health care delivery process. It was also nonresponsive to the needs of the key stakeholders. Analysis of the case shows that clearly the formal methods adopted by the system analysts fell short of determining the rapid changes required for care. In particular this was an important issue, since the context of the British National Health Services posed pressures on individual trusts to be cost effective. This resulted in long term patients being moved out into the community. However, this richness in the context was overlooked by the analysts. They developed “logical” models of the system, which ended up in being “tidy pictures of reality” and were prescriptive and utterly inflexible. Structured Systems Analysis and Design Method (SSADM) was used as a modelling tool, which amplified the rational view of decision making and information technology (IT) applications (for more details on SSADM see Downs et al., 1988). The interpretations identified in the case show a clear mis-match between the formal models and perceptions of the system users who inevitably reflect a more informal and pragmatic approach to their own organizational realities. The analysis of the case poses a number of interesting issues. It questions the relationship between the complexity of the social relations and systems design. Furthermore it brings to the fore the paradoxical viewpoints of different stakeholders and the emergent concerns for a system analyst. The chapter also identifies the impact of an “overformalized” information system on the integrity of an organization. In doing so it evaluates the nature and significance of social power structures in systems analysis, design and implementation.

Complete Chapter List

Search this Book:
Mehdi Khosrow-Pour
Chapter 1
Bing Wang, David Paper
This case study documents an organizational change intervention concerning the implementation of a novel information technology at a... Sample PDF
A Case of an IT-Enabled Organizational Change Intervention: The Missing Pieces
Chapter 2
Maha Shakir, Dennis Viehland
The Health Board is one of the largest public health care providers in New Zealand (NZ). In early 1999, a supply chain optimization review... Sample PDF
The Selection of the IT Platform: Enterprise System Implementation in the NZ Health Board
Chapter 3
K. R. Lang
The case study describes the implementation of a workflow management application at large media company. It shows how an organization created... Sample PDF
Workflow-Supported Invoice Management: The Case of a System Implementation
Chapter 4
Nina McGarry, Tom Beckman
This case describes the difficulties and successes encountered in a reengineering effort. A team of consultants undertook reengineering the delivery... Sample PDF
Business Reengineering at a Large Government Agency
Chapter 5
M. Sklar, I. Yermish
This case describes the process by which a conglomerate subsidiary of a larger enterprise chooses an ERP package. Conflicting goals faced by... Sample PDF
ERP Selection at AmBuildPro
Chapter 6
J. Gebauer, H. Schad
This case enumerates how Lawrence Livermore National Laboratories’ Zephyr System demonstrates how emerging technologies can help streamline... Sample PDF
Building an Internet-Based Workflow System: The Case of Lawrence Livermore National Laboratories' Zephyr Project
Chapter 7
D. Paper, J. Rodger
This case study describes the implementation of a novel information system that facilitates automation of business processes. The novel system... Sample PDF
Building Automation into Existing Business Processes
Chapter 8
J.-P. Kuilboer
This case addresses many of the causes of IS project failure. It is based on an information system redesign project undertaken by a State Social... Sample PDF
Information Systems Redesign in a State Social Services Agency: A Case Study
Chapter 9
J. Crnkovic, G. Petkovic
The case study describes a process of successful re-engineering small Yugoslavian showroom wholesale company (“Wissol”) during the period of economy... Sample PDF
Reengineering the Selling Process in a Showroom
Chapter 10
T. Whalen, D. Wright
This case describes the Bell Online Institute (BOLI) which represents a radical change to the way Bell Canada provides internal training to its... Sample PDF
Business Process Reengineering for the Use of Distance Learning at Bell Canada
Chapter 11
W. L. Kuechler
The case study describes the first four years of the radical reorganization of the Nevada Department of Motor Vehicles. The primary focus is on the... Sample PDF
Everyone's Watching: The Remarkably Public Reorganization of the Nevada Department of Motor Vehicles
Chapter 12
David Paper, Steve Dickinson
This case, coauthored by a process improvement manager, looks at business process reengineering (BPR) and discusses how it has received considerable... Sample PDF
A Comprehensive Process Improvement Methodology: Experiences at Caterpillar's Mossville Engine Center (MEC)
Chapter 13
D. Paper
Although numerous firms have experimented with business process reengineering (BPR), many have achieved less than dramatic results (Davenport, 1993;... Sample PDF
Reinventing Business Processes Through Automation: A Case Study
Chapter 14
E. M.W. Ng, P. Banerjee
The case study describes the Dairy Farm Group of Companies which is a conglomerate of supermarkets, hypermarkets, convenience stores and drugstores... Sample PDF
The Dilemma of Dairy Farm Group between Redesigning of Business Processes and Rebuilding of Management Information Systems
Chapter 15
G. Kim, J. Price
To facilitate the parent company’s push to gain market share, Heineken USA needed to be more responsive to market demand fluctuation. Because of the... Sample PDF
Heineken USA: Reengineering Distribution with HOPS
Chapter 16
T. Sinkkonen
This case examines the business practices of a small company in North-West Tasmania and identifies problems and challenges for electronic supply... Sample PDF
Identifying Business Processes for, and Challenges to, Electronic Supply Chain Management: A Case Study in a Small Business in North-West Tasmania, Australia
Chapter 17
P. Banerjee
The case study describes process reengineering at a major public bank of India. Choice between strategy, structure, technology, process and... Sample PDF
Incentives and Knowledge Mismatch: The Deemed Failure of a BPR Project in a Large Banking Organisation
Chapter 18
M. Schallert
Travel and related expenses account on average for 7% of an organization’s total operating costs and are escalating to be the second largest... Sample PDF
Business Process Redesign in Travel Management in an SAP R/3 Upgrade Project: A Case Study
Chapter 19
S. Sarker
The case study describes the process of implementation of an integrated software package at the Thai subsidiary (SMTL) of a Hong Kong-based... Sample PDF
Implementation Failure of an Integrated Software Package: A Case Study from the Far East
Chapter 20
Erik Frokjaer, Helge Korsbaek
This case summarizes the organizational transformations in the Danish mapping, charting and geodata sector from the mid-eighties to the mid-... Sample PDF
The Managerial Challenges in the Transformation of the Danish Geodata Sector
Chapter 21
Gurpreet Dhillon
The case study described in this chapter concerns the introduction of a new computer based integrated Clinical Information System (CIS) into a... Sample PDF
The Clinical Information System: A Case of Misleading Design Decisions
About the Editor