Denoising and Contrast Enhancement in Dental Radiography

Denoising and Contrast Enhancement in Dental Radiography

N.A. Borghese (University of Milano, Italy) and I. Frosio (University of Milano, Italy)
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60566-292-3.ch006
OnDemand PDF Download:


This chapter shows how large improvement in image quality can be obtained when radiographs are filtered using adequate statistical models. In particular, it shows that impulsive noise, which appears as random patterns of light and dark pixels on raw radiographs, can be efficiently removed. A switching median filter is used to this aim: failed pixels are identified first and then corrected through local median filtering. The critical stage is the correct identification of the failed pixels. We show here that a great improvement can be obtained considering an adequate sensor model and a principled noise distribution, constituted of a mixture of photon counting and impulsive noise with uniform distribution. It is then shown that contrast in cephalometric images can be largely increased using different grey levels stretching for bone and soft tissues. The two tissues are identified through an adequate mixture derived from histogram analysis, composed of two Gaussians and one inverted log-normal. Results show that both soft and bony tissues become clearly visible in the same image under a wider range of conditions. Both filters work in quasi-real time for images larger than five Mega-pixels.
Chapter Preview


Principled statistical models have been introduced in the imaging field as an effective alternative to classical linear and non-linear filtering. The first efficient statistical algorithms were first introduced in the fields of astrophysics (Lucy 1974, Richardson 1974) and PET imaging (Shepp and Vardi 1982). In these pioneering works the Poisson nature of the noise was first taken into account explicitly in the filtering stage. This leads to the formulation of a non-linear problem, where the cost function is named Kullback-Liebler divergence or Csizar divergence (Csizar 1991). Its minimization can be carried out efficiently through the Expectation Maximization algorithm, that is an iterative approach for estimating the parameters of a statistical model. EM iterates between the computation of an Expectation function, which describes the expected value of the negative log-likelihood over a set of latent variables, and the Maximization of this function, which allows adjusting the values of the parameters (Bishop 2006).

It was soon clear that considering an adequate model of the noise, much better results could be obtained. The price to be paid was a large increase in computational time. This was an obstacle to extend more principled statistical approaches to real problems and only few attempts were made in this direction (Geman and Geman 1984) until the last decade, in which computational power has made feasible this approach.

In this chapter, it is shown how using principled statistical models, two of the major problems in radiographic imaging can be reliably solved: impulsive noise removal, which is a common problem for any digital radiograph, and contrast enhancement in cephalometric radiography, where the anatomical structures of both soft and bone tissue have to be both clearly visible in the same image (Figure 1).

Figure 1.

In panel (a), a raw cephalometric image is shown. The same image is shown: in panel (b) after the application of UM (mask size 26 x 26, gain 3); after GC (γ = 0.5) + UM in panel (c); after HE + UM in panel (d); after STF (γBone = 0.25, γSoft = 1.25, TP = 52) + UM in panel (e). The rectangle highlighted in panel (e) is shown in panel (f) at a higher magnification rate (100 x 100 pixels are shown here); notice the presence of impulsive noise in this area.

The method described in the first part of this chapter is based on the observation that two are the main noise components on a radiograph. The first one, called impulsive noise, shows up as a random pattern of light and dark pixels, which changes from image to image. It may be attributed to transient failures of the A/D converter or communication over the bus of the sensor. The second noise component is due to the emission statistics of the X-ray photons, which is considered typically Poisson (Webb 1988). Impulsive noise badly affects both readability of images and further processing. Therefore, before providing the radiograph to the clinician, this noise component has to be corrected, often in a transparent way, at the driver level.

The classical approach to impulsive noise removal is based on a two stages procedure: pulses are detected first and then the image is filtered only in correspondence of the failed pixels; a local median filter is used to avoid the modification of any pixel but the failed ones. This approach has been named switching median filtering (Alparone Baronti and Carla 1995).

However, as shown in Figure 2 and Figure 3, the number of false positives identified by traditional switching median filters (consider for instance the Rank Conditioned Filter (RCF) by Alparone Baronti and Carla 1995) is quite large with a consequent significant low-pass filtering effect and loss of details. This has suggested developing better schemes for pulse identification.

Complete Chapter List

Search this Book:
Editorial Advisory Board
Table of Contents
Petros Koidis
Andriani Daskalaki
Andriani Daskalaki
Chapter 1
Demetrios J. Halazonetis
Cephalometric analysis has been a routine diagnostic procedure in Orthodontics for more than 60 years, traditionally employing the measurement of... Sample PDF
Software Support for Advanced Cephalometric Analysis in Orthodontics
Chapter 2
Jorg Hendricks, Gert Wollny, Alexander Hemprich, Thomas Hierl
This chapter presents a toolchain including image segmentation, rigid registration and a voxel based non-rigid registration as well as 3D... Sample PDF
A New Software Environment for 3D-Time Series Analysis
Chapter 3
Antheunis Versluis, Daranee Tantbirojn
Residual stress due to polymerization shrinkage of restorative dental materials has been associated with a number of clinical symptoms, ranging from... Sample PDF
Relationship Between Shrinkage and Stress
Chapter 4
Andreas Vogel
This chapter introduces a computer-controlled method for mandible alignment. The exact positioning of the mandible in relation to the maxilla is... Sample PDF
An Objective Registration Method for Mandible Alignment
Chapter 5
Thomas Hierl, Heike Huempfner-Hierl, Daniel Kruber, Thomas Gaebler, Alexander Hemprich, Gert Wollny
This chapter discusses the requirements of an image analysis tool designed for dentistry and oral and maxillofacial surgery focussing on 3D-image... Sample PDF
Requirements for a Universal Image Analysis Tool in Dentistry and Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery
Chapter 6
N.A. Borghese, I. Frosio
This chapter shows how large improvement in image quality can be obtained when radiographs are filtered using adequate statistical models. In... Sample PDF
Denoising and Contrast Enhancement in Dental Radiography
Chapter 7
Ralf K.W. Schulze
Established techniques for three-dimensional radiographic reconstruction such as computed tomography (CT) or, more recently cone beam computed... Sample PDF
3D Reconstructions from Few Projections in Oral Radiology
Chapter 8
Shital Patel, Yos Morsi
Tooth loss due to several reasons affects most people adversely at some time in their lives. A biological tooth substitute, which could not only... Sample PDF
Advances and Trends in Tissue Engineering of Teeth
Chapter 9
Wei-Bang Chen, Chengcui Zhang
Bacterial colony enumeration is an essential tool for many widely used biomedical assays. This chapter introduces a cost-effective and fully... Sample PDF
Automated Bacterial Colony Counting for Clonogenic Assay
Chapter 10
Michele Jacotti, Domenico Ciambrone
In this chapter the authors describe a new system for guided surgery in implantology. The aim of this system is to have a “user friendly”... Sample PDF
A New System in Guided Surgery: The Flatguide(TM) System
Chapter 11
Ferenc Pongracz
Intraoperative transfer of the implant and prosthesis planning in dentistry is facilitated by drilling templates or active, image-guided navigation.... Sample PDF
Visualization and Modelling in Dental Implantology
Chapter 12
Antonios Zampelis, George Tsamasphyros
Biomechanical research has gained recognition in medical sciences. Osseointegrated dental implants, being medical devices functioning under constant... Sample PDF
Finite Element Analysis and its Application in Dental Implant Research
Chapter 13
Amit Chattopadhyay, Tiago Coelho de Souza, Oscar Arevalo
Electronic Oral Health Records (EOHRs) contains all personal health information belonging to an individual and is entered and accessed... Sample PDF
Electronic Oral Health Records in Practice and Research
Chapter 14
Maxim Kolesnikov, Arnold D. Steinberg, Milos Zefran
This chapter describes the haptic dental simulator developed at the University of Illinois at Chicago. It explores its use and advantages as an... Sample PDF
Haptic-Based Virtual Reality Dental Simulator as an Educational Tool
Chapter 15
Anka Letic-Gavrilovic
In this chapter, the author will demonstrate and describe a project to develop a unique database with multilingual information and knowledge... Sample PDF
Digital Library for Dental Biomaterials
Chapter 16
Petros Koidis, Marianthi Manda
The present chapter deals with the introduction and implementation of rapid prototyping technologies in medical and dental field. Its purpose is to... Sample PDF
Rapid Prototyping and Dental Applications
Chapter 17
Hiroo Tamagawa, Hideaki Amano, Naoji Hayashi, Yasuyuki Hirose
In this chapter, the authors report the minimal set of characters from the Unicode Standard that is sufficient for the notation of human dentition... Sample PDF
Unicode Characters for Human Dentition: New Foundation for Standardized Data Exchange and Notation in Countries Employing Double-Byte Character Sets
Chapter 18
Nikos Nikolaidis, Ioannis Marras, Georgios Mikrogeorgis, Kleoniki Lyroudia, Ioannis Pitas
The availability of datasets comprising of digitized images of human body cross sections (as well as images acquired with other modalities such as... Sample PDF
Virtual Dental Patient: A 3D Oral Cavity Model and its Use in Haptics-Based Virtual Reality Cavity Preparation in Endodontics
About the Contributors