An Empirical Study on the Migration to OpenOffice.org in a Public Administration

An Empirical Study on the Migration to OpenOffice.org in a Public Administration

B. B. Rossi (Free University of Bolzano-Bozen, Italy), M. Scotto (Free University of Bolzano-Bozen, Italy), A. Sillitti (Free University of Bolzano-Bozen, Italy) and G. Succi (Free University of Bolzano-Bozen, Italy)
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60566-418-7.ch005
OnDemand PDF Download:
$37.50

Abstract

The aim of the paper is to report the results of a migration to Open Source Software (OSS) in one Public Administration. The migration focuses on the office automation field and, in particular, on the OpenOf- fice.org suite. We have analysed the transition to OSS considering qualitative and quantitative data collected with the aid of different tools. All the data have been always considered from the point of view of the different stakeholders involved, IT managers, IT technicians, and users. The results of the project have been largely satisfactory. However the results cannot be generalised due to some constraints, like the environment considered and the parallel use of the old solution. Nevertheless, we think that the data collected can be of valuable aid to managers wishing to evaluate a possible transition to OSS.
Chapter Preview
Top

Introduction

Open Source Software (OSS) and Open Data Standards (ODS) emerged in recent years as a viable alternative to proprietary solutions. There are many cases in which the adoption of OSS has proven advantageous for companies deciding to adopt it in replacement or in conjunction with closed solutions. The limitation of these migrations for our point of view is that they were very often server-side oriented and not supported by empirical evidence of the benefits of the new solution. In this sense, there are very few case studies that report successful transitions on the desktop side (ZDNet, 2005) and some are still underway (Landeshauptstadt München, 2003; Stadt Wien, 2004). It is our opinion that the reason of the apparent different results in the two fields is due to the nature of OSS development (Feller & Fitzgerald, 2001) that leads to repercussions on the resulting usability (Nichols & Twidale, 2003).

When comparing OSS and proprietary software and when comparing software solutions in general, it is impossible to get a global index referring to quality in order to compare two solutions (Fenton & Pfleeger, 1997).

If we consider the most important aspects under which it is significant to analyse software, as:

  • Reliability

  • Performance

  • Price

  • Security

  • Interoperability

  • Usability

  • Extendibility

  • Functionalities

  • Privacy protection

The categories have to be balanced with the requirements of the environment and users in which the solution is deployed. Where the aspects of security, reliability, and extendibility are of key importance, OSS has proven a valid solution, if not superior to proprietary solutions. Where functionalities, usability, and in general user interaction acquires importance as on the client side, OSS has yet to prove as a valid alternative. Price is a controversial issue as there is the need not only to evaluate the license price but also the software maintenance and other costs inherited from the migration. These considerations originated the study we propose.

The purpose of the study is to evaluate in a rigorous way the introduction of OSS in a working environment, following the criteria of a controlled experiment from the selection of the sample to the evaluation of the results. We selected a sample of 22 users from different offices in the public administration target of the experiment. We divided the sample in two groups, one to be migrated, the other to be used as a control group. The results obtained seem to report that the initial reduction of productivity is not as consistent as we thought, also taking into account that half of the users considered the introduced solution as offering less functionality than the proprietary one.

Top

State Of The Art

There are many studies available evaluating the Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) of OSS. The original model derived from the work of the Gartner Group in 1987 and has since then been inserted in different models. The TCO model helps managers by considering not only the cost of purchase but also further costs as maintenance or training.

All the studies are not unanimous as the savings that can be reached with the adoption of OSS (Robert Frances Group, 2002; The Yankee Group, 2005). One of the reasons is probably the different weight given to costs and benefits that are difficult to measure. Two of such measures are, for example, the risks of lock-ins and the development of local economies. The risks of entering a mechanism of lock-in, for example, by relying only on a single software supplier or storing massive amounts of data by means of closed data standards are real and must be considered in a TCO model evaluating a transition (Shapiro & Varian, 1999). On the other side, the adoption of OSS can be of benefit to local software companies that can exploit the possibility given by the available source code and open data standards. Also in this case, the amount of this kind of externality is difficult to quantify.

Complete Chapter List

Search this Book:
Reset
Editorial Advisory Board
Table of Contents
Chapter 1
Olivier Berger, Christian Bac, Benoît Hamet
Libre software provides powerful applications ready to be integrated for the build-up of platforms for internal use in organizations. We describe... Sample PDF
Integration of Libre Software Applications to Create a Collaborative Work Platform for Researchers at GET
$37.50
Chapter 2
James Howison, Megan Conklin, Kevin Crowston
This paper introduces and expands on previous work on a collaborative project, called FLOSSmole (formerly OSSmole), designed to gather, share and... Sample PDF
FLOSSmole: A Collaborative Repository for FLOSS Research Data and Analyses
$37.50
Chapter 3
Luis López-Fernández, Gregorio Robles, Jesus M. Gonzalez-Barahona, Israel Herraiz
Source code management repositories of large, long-lived libre (free, open source) software projects can be a source of valuable data about the... Sample PDF
Applying Social Network Analysis Techniques to Community-Driven Libre Software Projects
$37.50
Chapter 4
Walt Scacchi, Chris Jensen, John Noll, Margaret Elliott
Understanding the context, structure, activities, and content of software development processes found in practice has been and remains a challenging... Sample PDF
Multi-Modal Modeling, Analysis, and Validation of Open Source Software Development Processes
$37.50
Chapter 5
B. B. Rossi, M. Scotto, A. Sillitti, G. Succi
The aim of the paper is to report the results of a migration to Open Source Software (OSS) in one Public Administration. The migration focuses on... Sample PDF
An Empirical Study on the Migration to OpenOffice.org in a Public Administration
$37.50
Chapter 6
Claudio Agostino Ardagna, Fulvio Frati, Gabriele Gianini
Business and recreational activities on the global communication infrastructure are increasingly based on the use of remote resources and services... Sample PDF
Open Source in Web-Based Applications: A Case Study on Single Sign-On
$37.50
Chapter 7
Qusay H. Mahmoud, Zakaria Maamar
Conventional desktop software applications are usually designed, built, and tested on a platform similar to the one on which they will be deployed... Sample PDF
Engineering Wireless Mobile Applications
$37.50
Chapter 8
G. Sivaradje, R. Nakkeeran, P. Dananjayan
In this paper, a novel prediction technique is proposed, which uses road topology information for prediction. The proposed scheme uses real time... Sample PDF
A Prediction Based Flexible Channel Assignment in Wireless Networks using Road Topology Information
$37.50
Chapter 9
Hesham A. Ali, Tamer Ahmed Farrag
Due to the rapidly increasing of the mobile devices connected to the internet, a lot of researches are being conducted to maximize the benefit of... Sample PDF
High Performance Scheduling Mechanism for Mobile Computing Based on Self-Ranking Algorithm (SRA)
$37.50
Chapter 10
Khaldoon Al-Zoubi
This paper proposes hierarchal scheduling schemes for Grid systems: a self-discovery scheme for the resource discovery stage and an adaptive child... Sample PDF
Hierarchical Scheduling in Heterogeneous Grid Systems
$37.50
Chapter 11
Amjad Mahmood, Taher S.K. Homeed
Object replication is a well-known technique to improve performance of a distributed Web server system. This paper first presents an algorithm to... Sample PDF
Object Grouping and Replication on a Distributed Web Server System
$37.50
Chapter 12
Saher S. Manaseer, Mohamed Ould-Khaoua, Lewis M. Mackenzie
In wireless communication environments, backoff is traditionally based on the IEEE binary exponential backoff (BEB). Using BEB results in a high... Sample PDF
On the Logarithmic Backoff Algorithm for MAC Protocol in MANETs
$37.50
Chapter 13
Xunhua Wang, David Rine
Domain Name System (DNS) is the system for the mapping between easily memorizable host names and their IP addresses. Due to its criticality, the... Sample PDF
Secure Online DNS Dynamic Updates: Architecture and Implementation
$37.50
Chapter 14
Osama H.S. Khader
In mobile ad hoc networks, routing protocols are becoming more complicated and problematic. Routing in mobile ad hoc networks is multi-hop because... Sample PDF
FSR Evaluation Using the Suboptimal Operational Values
$37.50
Chapter 15
Suet Chun Lee
Software product line (SPL) is a software engineering paradigm for software development. A software product within a product line often has specific... Sample PDF
Modeling Variant User Interfaces for Web-Based Software Product Lines
$37.50
Chapter 16
M. Brian Blake, Lisa Singh, Andrew B. Williams, Wendell Norman, Amy L. Sliva
Organizations are beginning to apply data mining and knowledge discovery techniques to their corporate data sets, thereby enabling the... Sample PDF
Experience Report: A Component-Based Data Management and Knowledge Discovery Framework for Aviation Studies
$37.50
Chapter 17
A. F. Tappenden, T. Huynh, J. Miller, A. Geras, M. Smith
This article outlines a four-point strategy for the development of secure Web-based applications within an agile development framework and... Sample PDF
Agile Development of Secure Web-Based Applications
$37.50
Chapter 18
D. Xuan Le, J. Wenny Rahayu, David Taniar
This paper proposes a data warehouse integration technique that combines data and documents from different underlying documents and database design... Sample PDF
Web Data Warehousing Convergence: From Schematic to Systematic
$37.50
Chapter 19
Haya El-Ghalayini, Mohammed Odeh, Richard McClatchey
This paper studies the differences and similarities between domain ontologies and conceptual data models and the role that ontologies can play in... Sample PDF
Engineering Conceptual Data Models from Domain Ontologies: A Critical Evaluation
$37.50
Chapter 20
John D. Ferguson, James Miller
It is now widely accepted that software projects utilizing the Web (e-projects) face many of the same problems and risks experienced with more... Sample PDF
Modeling Defects in E-Projects
$37.50
Chapter 21
Jaime Gomez, Alejandro Bia, Antonio Parraga
This paper describes the engineering foundations of VisualWADE, a CASE tool to automate the production of Web applications. VisualWADE follows a... Sample PDF
Tool Support for Model-Driven Development of Web Applications
$37.50
About the Editors