Evaluation of Medical Image Compression

Evaluation of Medical Image Compression

C. Delgorge-Rosenberger (Universite d’Orleans, France) and C. Rosenberger (GREYC - ENSICAEN - Universite Caen Basse Normandie, France)
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60566-314-2.ch028
OnDemand PDF Download:


The authors present in this chapter an overview on evaluation of medical image compression. The different methodologies used in the literature are presented. Subjective evaluation uses some a priori knowledge such as the judgment of experts or the ability to realize a correct diagnosis. Objective evaluation generally takes into account the value of metrics: the PSNR is an example of such a criterion. The goal of hybrid evaluation is to realize a reliable judgment while having a simple computation. The authors discuss on the benefits and drawbacks of these approaches. The European Project called OTELO in which they were involved, gives feedback on ultrasound image compression.
Chapter Preview


Medical imaging is an important and a powerful technique whose goal is to facilitate the expert diagnosis. Many image processing algorithms can be used within this context such as: image filtering, compression, segmentation, interpretation or retrieval... One important issue concerns the evaluation of different image processing results for the medical expert: as for example, image filtering can improve the image quality but can disturb the ability of a medical expert to make a diagnosis.

The proposed chapter deals with the particular field of the evaluation of medical image compression. Image compression for medical applications is an important topic as many image acquisitions are transmitted and stored for a further analysis. In this context, we want to minimize the size of the compressed image while keeping a sufficient quality for the diagnosis. Several evaluation methods have been proposed in the state of the art. We propose in this chapter to make an overview of these approaches. We present different evaluation techniques for either an expert in image processing or for a medical expert. We discuss the advantages and drawbacks of each method. The European OTELO project (Delgorge et al., 2005) in which we have been involved, provides a good experience feedback in the evaluation of medical image compression.

The main objective of the European OTELO project (mObile Tele-Echography with an ultra Light rObot) was to develop a robotic tele-echographic system. A light weight robot holds and moves a real probe on a distant patient according to the expert gesture and permits an image acquisition using a standard ultrasound device (see Figure 1). Ultrasound images constitute the only feedback information available to the medical expert to remotely control the distant robotized system. The expert controls the remote probe holder robot by using a dedicated input device and based on the quality of the received information. The diagnosis made by the specialist strongly depends on the quality of these images. An important task also concerns the evaluation of the quality of the compressed images. Many experimental results are presented in this chapter in order to illustrate the behaviors of the different evaluation methods.

Figure 1.

the OTELO tele-echographic system

We can distinguish three types of evaluation methods in the state of the art. The first one concerns the subjective evaluation. The quality of a compression result, for any medical types of images, is traditionally evaluated by considering a visual test where many experts examine a large set of images and score each one based on their quality or the ability to make a correct diagnosis. Second, we present the objective evaluation methods. Many statistical criteria have been proposed in the literature to automatically evaluate different compression results of a single image. We propose to compare many of them and discuss their efficiency. Subjective and objective evaluation methods have many advantages and drawbacks. These two approaches are complementary. That is why many works propose an hybrid approach. These methods are presented in the main trust of this article. The goal of these methods is to make a reliable judgment (similar to a medical expert) while using some statistical criteria to make the evaluation of a large set of compression results possible. The future trends in the domain are then proposed and a conclusion is given.



Image compression is an important issue in medical imaging as the distant visualization of medical images is now possible through high bandwidth networks for different applications (discussion between experts on a difficult case, storage of medical images of a patient...) and as telemedecine becomes an emergent technology nowadays (Delgorge et al., 2005).

Image compression is an image processing algorithm whose objective is to decrease the size of storage of the image while preserving as much as possible its visual quality (see Figure 2). Even if this definition is quite simple, the main problem is to evaluate the quality of a compression result. As for example, the result given in Figure 2 is clearly not very good but it is difficult to say if this quality would be satisfactory for a medical expert to make a diagnosis.

Figure 2.

Example of a JPEG compression result (ratio 5%) of an ultrasound image

Key Terms in this Chapter

Subjective Evaluation: It is a quantitative or a qualitative evaluation involving experts or some a priori knowledge.

Human Visual System (HVS): It refers to the visual perception of humans that is simulated by researchers in evaluation.

Objective Evaluation: It is a quantitative evaluation generally based on statistical criteria. None a priori knowledge is used for the evaluation.

Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC): ROC curves provides tools to analysis the behavior of models, algorithms or human judgments.

Peak Signal-to-Noise Ratio (PSNR): The PSNR is most commonly used as a measure of quality of reconstruction in image compression.

Fusion: Combination of different data in order to improve decision making.

Hybrid Evaluation: The goal of this approach is to obtain a judgment as reliable as the subjective one while having an easy computation.

Complete Chapter List

Search this Book:
Editorial Advisory Board
Table of Contents
Themis P. Exarchos, Athanasios Papadopoulos, Dimitrios I. Fotiadis
Chapter 1
Ioannis Dimou, Michalis Zervakis, David Lowe, Manolis Tsiknakis
The automation of diagnostic tools and the increasing availability of extensive medical datasets in the last decade have triggered the development... Sample PDF
Computational Methods and Tools for Decision Support in Biomedicine: An Overview of Algorithmic Challenges
Chapter 2
William Hsu, Alex A.T. Bui, Ricky K. Taira, Hooshang Kangarloo
Though an unparalleled amount and diversity of imaging and clinical data are now collected as part of routine care, this information is not... Sample PDF
Integrating Imaging and Clinical Data for Decision Support
Chapter 3
Spyretta Golemati, John Stoitsis, Konstantina S. Nikita
The estimation of motion of the myocardial and arterial wall is important for the quantification of tissue elasticity and contractility and has... Sample PDF
Analysis and Quantification of Motion within the Cardiovascular System: Implications for the Mechanical Strain of Cardiovascular Structures
Chapter 4
Christos V. Bourantas, Katerina Naka, Dimitrios Fotiadis, Lampros Michalis
Intracoronary Ultrasound (ICUS) imaging is an intravascular catheter-based technique which provides real-time, high resolution, cross-sectional... Sample PDF
New Developments in Intracoronary Ultrasound Processing
Chapter 5
Stavroula Mougiakakou, Ioannis Valavanis, Alexandra Nikita, Konstantina S. Nikita
Recent advances in computer science provide the intelligent computation tools needed to design and develop Diagnostic Support Systems (DSSs) that... Sample PDF
Diagnostic Support Systems and Computational Intelligence: Differential Diagnosis of Hepatic Lesions from Computed Tomography Images
Chapter 6
Marotesa Voultsidou, J. Michael Herrmann
Indicative features of an fMRI data set can be evaluated by methods provided by theory of random matrices (RMT). RMT considers ensembles of matrices... Sample PDF
Significance Estimation in fMRI from Random Matrices
Chapter 7
Dimitrios C. Karampinos, Robert Dawe, Konstantinos Arfanakis, John G. Georgiadis
Diffusion Magnetic Resonance Imaging (diffusion MRI) can provide important information about tissue microstructure by probing the diffusion of water... Sample PDF
Optimal Diffusion Encoding Strategies for Fiber Mapping in Diffusion MRI
Chapter 8
Dimitrios G. Tsalikakis, Petros S. Karvelis, Dimitrios I. Fotiadis
Segmentation plays a crucial role in cardiac magnetic resonance imaging (CMRI) applications, since it permits automated detection of regions of... Sample PDF
Segmentation of Cardiac Magnetic Resonance Images
Chapter 9
Katia Marina Passera, Luca Tommaso Mainardi
Image registration is the process of determining the correspondence of features between images collected at different times or using different... Sample PDF
Image Registration Algorithms for Applications in Oncology
Chapter 10
Lena Costaridou, Spyros Skiadopoulos, Anna Karahaliou, Nikolaos Arikidis, George Panayiotakis
Breast cancer is the most common cancer in women worldwide. Mammography is currently the most effective modality in detecting breast cancer... Sample PDF
Computer-Aided Diagnosis in Breast Imaging: Trends and Challenges
Chapter 11
E. Kyriacou, C.I. Christodoulou, C. Loizou, M.S. Pattichis, C.S. Pattichis, S. Kakkos
Stroke is the third leading cause of death in the Western world and a major cause of disability in adults. The objective of this work was to... Sample PDF
Assessment of Stroke by Analysing Cartoid Plaque Morphology
Chapter 12
Marios Neofytou, Constantinos Pattichis, Vasilios Tanos, Marios Pattichis, Eftyvoulos Kyriacou
The objective of this chapter is to propose a quantitative hysteroscopy imaging analysis system in gynaecological cancer and to provide the current... Sample PDF
Quantitative Analysis of Hysteroscopy Imaging in Gynecological Cancer
Chapter 13
Thomas V. Kilindris, Kiki Theodorou
Patient anatomy, biochemical response, as well functional evaluation at organ level, are key fields that produce a significant amount of multi modal... Sample PDF
Combining Geometry and Image in Biomedical Systems: The RT TPS Case
Chapter 14
Ioannis Tsougos, George Loudos, Panagiotis Georgoulias, Konstantina S. Nikita, Kiki Theodorou
Quantitative three-dimensional nuclear medical imaging plays a continuously increasing role in radionuclide dosimetry, allowing the development of... Sample PDF
Internal Radionuclide Dosimetry using Quantitative 3-D Nuclear Medical Imaging
Chapter 15
Evanthia E. Tripoliti, Dimitrios I. Fotiadis, Konstantia Veliou
Diffusion Tensor Imaging (DTI) is a magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) modality which can significantly improve our understanding of the brain... Sample PDF
Diffusion Tensor Imaging and Fiber Tractography
Chapter 16
Anastasios Koutlas, Dimitrios I. Fotiadis
The aim of this chapter is to analyze the recent advances in image processing and machine learning techniques with respect to facial expression... Sample PDF
Image Processing and Machine Learning Techniques for Facial Expression Recognition
Chapter 17
Arcangelo Merla
This chapter presents an overview on recent developments in the field of clinical applications of the functional infrared imaging. The functional... Sample PDF
Developments and Advances in Biomedical Functional Infrared Imaging
Chapter 18
Aristotelis Chatziioannou, Panagiotis Moulos
The completion of the Human Genome Project and the emergence of high-throughput technologies at the dawn of the new millennium, are rapidly changing... Sample PDF
DNA Microarrays: Analysis and Interpretation
Chapter 19
Nikolaos Giannakeas, Dimitrios I. Fotiadis
Microarray technology allows the comprehensive measurement of the expression level of many genes simultaneously on a common substrate. Typical... Sample PDF
Image Processing and Machine Learning Techniques for the Segmentation of cDNA
Chapter 20
Petros S. Karvelis, Dimitrios I. Fotiadis
Automated chromosome analysis is now becoming routine in most human cytogenetics laboratories. It involves both processing and analysis of digital... Sample PDF
Recent Advances in Automated Chromosome Image Analysis
Chapter 21
O. Lezoray, G. Lebrun, C. Meurie, C. Charrier, A. Elmotataz, M. Lecluse
The segmentation of microscopic images is a challenging application that can have numerous applications ranging from prognosis to diagnosis.... Sample PDF
Machine Learning in Morphological Segmentation
Chapter 22
Michael Haefner, Alfred Gangl, Michael Liedlgruber, A. Uhl, Andreas Vecsei, Friedrich Wrba
Wavelet-, Fourier-, and spatial domain-based texture classification methods have been used successfully for classifying zoom-endoscopic colon images... Sample PDF
Pit Pattern Classification Using Multichannel Features and Multiclassification
Chapter 23
C. Papaodysseus, P. Rousopoulos, D. Arabadjis, M. Panagopoulos, P. Loumou
In this chapter the state of the art is presented in the domain of automatic identification and classification of bodies on the basis of their... Sample PDF
Automatic Identification and Elastic Properties of Deformed Objects Using their Microscopic Images
Chapter 24
Alexia Giannoula, Richard S.C. Cobbold
“Elastography” or “elasticity imaging” can be defined as the science and methodology of estimating the mechanical properties of a medium (including... Sample PDF
Nonlinear Ultrasound Radiation-Force Elastography
Chapter 25
Valentina Russo, Roberto Setola
The aim of this chapter is to provide an overview about models and methodologies used for the Dynamic Contrast Enhancement (DCE) analysis. DCE is a... Sample PDF
Dynamic Contrast Enhancement: Analysis's Models and Methodologies
Chapter 26
George K. Matsopoulos
The accurate estimation of point correspondences is often required in a wide variety of medical image processing applications including image... Sample PDF
Automatic Correspondence Methods towards Point-Based Medical Image Registration: An Evaluation Study
Chapter 27
Alberto Taboada-Crispi, Hichem Sahli, Denis Hernandez-Pacheco, Alexander Falcon-Ruiz
Various approaches have been taken to detect anomalies, with certain particularities in the medical image scenario, linked to other terms... Sample PDF
Anomaly Detection in Medical Image Analysis
Chapter 28
C. Delgorge-Rosenberger, C. Rosenberger
The authors present in this chapter an overview on evaluation of medical image compression. The different methodologies used in the literature are... Sample PDF
Evaluation of Medical Image Compression
Chapter 29
Charalampos Doukas, Ilias Maglogiannis
Medical images are often characterized by high complexity and consist of high resolution image files, introducing thus several issues regarding... Sample PDF
Advanced ROI Coding Techniques for Medical Imaging
Chapter 30
Farhang Sahba
Ultrasound imaging now has widespread clinical use. It involves exposing a part of the body to highfrequency sound waves in order to generate images... Sample PDF
Segmentation Methods in Ultrasound Images
About the Editors
About the Contributors