An Exploratory Investigation of the Barriers to the Adoption of Open Source ERP by Belgian SMEs
Kris Ven (University of Antwerp, Belgium) and Dieter Van Nuffel (University of Antwerp, Belgium)
Copyright © 2013.
OnDemand Chapter PDF Download
Download link provided immediately after order completion
Instant access upon order completion.
Notwithstanding the increasing interest in open source ERP (OS-ERP) products in the past few years, their adoption by Belgian organizations is still very limited. To gain more insight into this phenomenon, we performed an exploratory investigation of which barriers inhibit the adoption of OS-ERP by Belgian SMEs. Based upon our previous research, we identified two main barriers, namely a lack of functionality and a lack of support. Next, we performed a screening of the Belgian OS-ERP market to investigate the functionality and support offered by various OS-ERP products. This allowed us to determine how the perceptions of organizations compare to the actual market for OS-ERP in Belgium. Our results provide more insight into the barriers to the adoption of OS-ERP by Belgian SMEs and provide various avenues for future research.
In the past decade, open source software (OSS) has evolved significantly and has become a viable solution for organizations. The adoption of OSS has taken place in three different waves. The first wave of OSS adoption was focused on server-side applications such as Linux and Apache. This can be explained by the fact that most OSS development initially focused on horizontal domains such as Internet applications, developer tools and technical tools (Fitzgerald, 2005). As a result, server-side applications were the most mature OSS products available and were among the first OSS products to be adopted by organizations. Thanks to the increasing involvement of commercial software vendors in OSS development, many mature OSS products have appeared in other domains as well (Fitzgerald, 2006; Brydon & Vinning, 2008). The second wave of OSS adoption seems to be centering around the adoption of open source desktop software, such as OpenOffice.org and Firefox. Public administrations in particular have been rather active in exploring the possibilities of migrating towards OSS on desktop computers (Ven, Van Nuffel, & Verelst, 2007). Lately, several OSS products have become available in the enterprise application domain such as Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP), Supply Chain Management (SCM), Customer Relationship Management (CRM), and Enterprise Content Management (ECM). Hence, the OSS phenomenon has been gradually penetrating the whole software stack, going from the infrastructural level to the business application level. It has been argued that some OSS products may have the potential to gain entrance to and disrupt the commercial enterprise software market (Brydon & Vinning, 2008). The third wave of OSS adoption may therefore involve the adoption of open source enterprise software. In this chapter, our focus is on the adoption of open source Enterprise Resource Planning (OS-ERP). It can be observed that among the various open source enterprise software products, OS-ERP products are slowly gaining acceptance in organizations (Davis, 2008). It has also been noted that a relatively large number of new OSS projects are gradually appearing in this area (Johansson & Sudzina, 2008; Johansson & Sudzina, 2009).
Since the adoption of OS-ERP is a rather new phenomenon, it has not been studied extensively in academic literature yet and several authors have called for additional research on this topic (Kim & Boldyreff, 2005; de Carvalho, 2009; Davis, 2008). Some of the early studies in this domain have suggested a number of advantages of OS-ERP that may generate the interest of organizations to adopt. These advantages include: increased adaptability of the software thanks to the availability of the source code, possibility to realize cost savings, and reduced vendor lock-in (Serrano & Sarriegi, 2006; Johansson & Sudzina, 2008; de Carvalho & Johansson, 2010; Davis, 2008). A recent study among Belgian organizations has, however, shown that the adoption of open source enterprise software—including OS-ERP—is lagging far behind the adoption of OSS for desktop or server-side use (Ven, 2008). This suggests that several barriers exist with respect to the organizational adoption of OS-ERP. Given the fact that ERP systems are crucial for supporting the business activities of organizations, it is reasonable to expect that organizations may be rather hesitant to rely on an open source solution for their ERP needs. It has been suggested that possible reasons for this low degree of adoption include the lack of reliable, maintainable and scalable OS-ERP solutions (Davis, 2008).