Measuring ICT: Political and Methodological Aspects

Measuring ICT: Political and Methodological Aspects

Diego Giannone (University of Salerno, Italy)
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60566-254-1.ch012
OnDemand PDF Download:
$37.50

Abstract

Starting from the assumption that any technology embeds the ideology, politics and culture of the society where it was created, this chapter reconstructs the specific historical and political link between the affirmation of neo-liberal paradigm, which has occurred since the 1970s in Western industrialized capitalist countries, and the dissemination of ICT. More in particular, it analyses the problem of measurement of ICT, emerged functionally to the need to identify new tools to legitimize the hierarchy of development, giving some countries the label of “most advanced” and the others of “developing” or “underdeveloped”. Indeed, the measurement, acting as a scientific justification for the Western superiority, is a part of those structures of knowledge which constitute an essential element in the functioning and legitimacy of the political, economic and social structures of the existing world-system. This contribution reconstructs this methods of knowledge deployed first at the international level, within and through the work of those actors who have taken the leading role in defining the interpretative lines of the measurement of ICT: the OECD, ITU, the World Bank.
Chapter Preview
Top

Measuring Ict And The Neoliberal Project

The rapid diffusion of new information and communication technologies (ICT) is crucially linked to the early years (1970s) of their development. The paradigmatic changes occurring in that period in the industrialized countries of the capitalist West played a key role both in the dissemination of ICT and for their legitimacy as a criterion for measuring the progress of society. During the 70s, Western societies experienced a period of political, economic and social crisis becaus the Keynesian and welfare models, according to which they had been governed, were losing legitimacy because of creating ungovernable democracies. Therefore these models were deemed by then social systems unable to cope with the growing issues of the social body (Crozier, Huntington & Watanuki, 1975).

In the battle for a new hegemony, neoliberalism emerged as the best model for responding to the attempts to restore class power by the economic and political world elite (Harvey, 2005). Within a few years, the neoliberal doctrine, which had achieved a fundamental reversal of the existing balance in the relationship between the individual and society, economics and politics, public and private, was able to impose worldwide, even as regards the man in the street, a new vision of the world (Harvey, 2005).

There are many reasons why neoliberalism has been a suitable political-ideological terrain for the spreading of ICT and a justification and ideological legitimacy of their development. One possible explanation lies in the fact that, unlike the preceding welfare model, this doctrine maintains that:

the social good will be maximized by maximizing the reach and frequency of market transactions, and it seeks to bring all human action into the domain of the market. This requires technologies of information creation and capacities to accumulate, store, transfer, analyze, and use massive databases to guide decisions in the global marketplace. (Harvey, 2005, p. 3)

The trajectories of neoliberalism have therefore intersected with the incentive to produce new technology infrastructure (software and hardware),because it has been: (a) a new area of prolific development of the capitalist economy, (b) an effective solution to the decrease in production costs and the acceleration both of economic transactions and financialization of the economy, (c) an appropriate solution to the imperative of a more streamlined and less expensive statehood, (d) an ideological tool to reaffirm on a global scale the superiority of some countries over others. This last point deserves particular attention. Indeed, it is necessary to remember that:

the new information technologies were developed in, by and for highly advanced capitalist economies – that of the USA in particular. It is to be expected, therefore, that these technologies are now being employed single-mindedly to serve market objectives. Control of the labour force, higher productivity, capture of the world markets, and continued capital accumulation are the propelling influences under which the new information technologies are developed. (Schiller, 1985, p. 37)

Their legitimacy as a key element of the development of society took place in the historical period that marks the transition in terms of international relations from the framework of the “development project” to that of the “globalization project” (McMichael, 2004). This new frame of development dissemination, which the neoliberal doctrine put in place especially through the central role of international institutions (World Bank, International Monetary Fund),

succeed[ed] the development project, partly because the latter failed and partly because the former became a new exercise of (market) power across the world (as transnational firms and banks grew and as neoliberal ideology took hold, restructuring states and societies everywhere). (McMichael, 2004, p. XXXIX)

Complete Chapter List

Search this Book:
Reset
Editorial Advisory Board
Table of Contents
Acknowledgment
Francesco Amoretti
Chapter 1
Francesco Amoretti
In “Electronic Constitution: A Braudelian Perspective”, Francesco Amoretti presents a model for the analysis of time and space structures of digital... Sample PDF
Electronic Constitution: A Braudelian Perspective
$37.50
Chapter 2
Mauro Di Meglio, Enrico Gargiulo
This chapter offers a long-term perspective on citizenship, questioning one of the basic assumptions of most of the literature on this topic, that... Sample PDF
Old and New Rights: E-Citizenship in Historical Perspective
$37.50
Chapter 3
Oreste Ventrone
Following the diffusion of e-government in the high income countries, international organizations, notably UN, OECD, World Bank, have promoted the... Sample PDF
International Organizations, E-Government and Development
$37.50
Chapter 4
Fortunato Musella
The chapter is dedicated at analyzing the strategic use of new technologies in the United States. An evident synergy has been noted between the... Sample PDF
American Electronic Constitution: Reinventing Government and Neo-Liberal Corporatism
$37.50
Chapter 5
Francesco Amoretti, Fortunato Musella
The challenge of convergence has become a core issue in the European agenda, as the existence of widely accepted administrative standards represents... Sample PDF
The European Administrative Space and E-Government Policies: Between Integration and Competition
$37.50
Chapter 6
Clementina Casula
The rhetoric used worldwide by policymakers in promoting the uptake of Information and Communication Technologies (ICT) emphasizes the advantages... Sample PDF
The EU and the Information Society: From E-Knowledge to E-Inclusion, in Search of Global Leadership
$37.50
Chapter 7
Nicolas Pejout
Many of African States are focusing on ICTs and developing e-government infrastructures in order to fasten and improve their “formalisation... Sample PDF
World Wide Weber: Formalise, Normalise, Rationalise
$37.50
Chapter 8
Joseph Ofori-Dankwa, Connie Ofori-Dankwa
Several African countries have begun to introduce and implement Information and Communication Technology (ICT) policies. In the context of such... Sample PDF
ICT Challenges and Opportunities for Institutionalizing Democracy in Ghana: An Integrative Review of the Literature
$37.50
Chapter 9
Chin-fu Hung
China has vigorously implemented ICTs to foster ongoing informatization accompanying industrialization as a crucial pillar to drive its future... Sample PDF
The Politics of the Governing the Information and Communications Technologies in East Asian Authoritarian States: Case Study of China
$37.50
Chapter 10
Claudia Padovani, Elena Pavan
Political processes are undergoing profound changes due to the challenges imposed by globalization processes to the legitimacy of policy actors and... Sample PDF
Information Networks, Internet Governance and Innovation in World Politics
$37.50
Chapter 11
Mauro Santaniello
The Internet Governance debate has, for a long time, been influenced by a well-defined characterization of information networks. The depiction of a... Sample PDF
Who Governs Cyberspace? Internet Governance and Power Structures in Digital Networks
$37.50
Chapter 12
Diego Giannone
Starting from the assumption that any technology embeds the ideology, politics and culture of the society where it was created, this chapter... Sample PDF
Measuring ICT: Political and Methodological Aspects
$37.50
Chapter 13
Paolo Landri
This chapter is dedicated to analyse the fabrication of networked socialities, that is to address the complex interweaving of technologies of... Sample PDF
The Fabrication of Networked Socialities
$37.50
Chapter 14
Virtual Nations  (pages 224-241)
William Sims Bainbridge
Virtual worlds are computer environments in which large numbers of human beings may interact, do useful work for each others, and build enduring... Sample PDF
Virtual Nations
$37.50
Chapter 15
Francesco Amoretti
This volume does not constitute yet another account of the blessings of ICTs. Nor does it add new criticism to the old, nurturing fears about the... Sample PDF
A Research Agenda for the Future
$37.50
About the Contributors