Modelling Trust–Control Dynamics for Grid-based Communities: A Shared Psychological Ownership Perspective

Modelling Trust–Control Dynamics for Grid-based Communities: A Shared Psychological Ownership Perspective

Marina Burakova-Lorgnier (University of Bordeaux 4, INSEEC Business Schools, France)
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60566-364-7.ch009
OnDemand PDF Download:
$37.50

Abstract

A Virtual Organisation (VO) or Virtual Enterprise is a loosely-coupled group of collaborating organisations, acting to some extent as though they were part of a single organisation. This implies that they exhibit some properties of a conventional organisation without actually being one. In practice, this involves overcoming organisational boundaries, which tend to make collaborative working difficult. The authors of this chapter propose that this is a socio-technical problem, requiring both a technical (software) infrastructure and a sociological approach to building, deploying and operating the VOs supported by it. This joint approach can help to overcome some of the problems associated with collaborative working, ranging from poorly coordinated activity, to ineffective problem solving and decision- making. The authors describe a socio-technical approach to building and operating VOs in highly dynamic environments and present two factual scenarios from the chemical and health industries. They describe a platform supporting such VOs, which was developed as part of the EPSRC E-Science Pilot Project GOLD.
Chapter Preview
Top

Introduction

The main trend in the organisational behaviour research puts forward the importance of a minimum level of trust for the success of any form of collaboration (Bijlsma-Frankema & Costa, 2005). Numerous empirical studies (Clases et al., 2003; Das & Teng, 1998; McKnight et al., 2004) have defined trust as a primary determinant of collaborative success. At the same time, Köller (1988) and McLain & Hackman (1999) have demonstrated that control reduces trust. This effect is due to certain social attribution mechanisms. First, mere presence of a control system causes the perception of partners as less trustworthy. Second, cooperation in the presence of a control system is attributed to the constraints imposed by the control system rather than trustworthiness, which inhibits the development of trust (Coletti et al., 2005). Some researchers (Das & Teng, 2001; Şengűn & Wasti, 2007), who reject the negative influence of control on trust development, believe that the negative effects of control systems are due to certain limitations of the previous studies. Coletti et al. (2005) even posit that control may enhance the level of trust between the partners.

It is clear that a collaborative environment, such as a grid-based community (GC), represents a challenge in terms of control. Attempts both to identify optimal levels of control mechanisms and to consider the impact of such mechanisms on interpersonal trust are undertaken (Coletti et al., 2005). The specificity of the GC stems from the following characteristics. First, a GC does not provide fixed paths towards the resources needed. Second, the resources per se are not constantly available, which results in the absence of the prescribed interaction patterns. Third, there is a high need for formal control mechanisms to maintain an efficient functioning of the community. Those mechanisms assure that all the processes within a GC run smoothly. Fourth, the resources exploited may be of a high level of confidence. Hence, resource sharing (an expression of trust and shared psychological ownership) and resource protection (an expression of personal control and individual psychological ownership) of resources may come to conflict. Any interaction contains an element of risk due to the fact that an interaction partner might not reciprocate (Stewart, 2003). Mediated interaction that characterises the GC context has a significantly higher level of risk as compared to face-to-face interaction (Ratnasingam, 2005). This inevitably brings up the questions of the routes of the risk reduction. Depending upon a conceptual position, both control and trust may be considered risk reducing mechanisms.

According to a few though rigorous empirical studies (Bijlsma-Frankema & Costa, 2005; Khodyakov, 2007; Şengűn & Wasti, 2007), trust does not develop without control. The relationship between trust and control is understood in the perspective of duality (Figure 1). In particular, trust is defined as a positive expectation about the outcome of an interaction based on the benevolence of the other party involved (Möllering, 2005). Trust is conceptualised through cognitive and affective dimensions (Mayer et al., 1995). Control is defined as a positive expectation about the outcome of an interaction based on the structural influences of the social system on the other party involved (Möllering, 2005). Control is conceptualised through internal and external dimensions (Berrenberg, 1987). The latter is, in turn subdivided into formal and social control (Khodyakov, 2007). There is empirical evidence that trust and control mutually influence each other. Thanks to the verification of the partner’s reputation, competencies and other capacities, formal control provides a basis for the cognitive trust development, which is nurtured by knowledge of the partner’s reliability (Coletti et al., 2005). Informal control influences both cognitive and affective trust (Şengűn & Wasti, 2007). Trust, in turn, makes possible the use of new policies and standards (measures of formal control), etc. (idem). (Figure 2)

Complete Chapter List

Search this Book:
Reset
Editorial Advisory Board
Table of Contents
Foreword
Mark Baker
Preface
Nik Bessis
Acknowledgment
Nik Bessis
Chapter 1
Enjie Liu, Xia Zhao, Gordon J. Clapworthy
At the heart of the Grid technology is the concept of resource sharing, which includes computers, storage and networks. Grid currently appears to be... Sample PDF
Building Service-Oriented Grid Applications
$37.50
Chapter 2
Giuseppe Andronico, Roberto Barbera, Marco Fargetta, Emidio Giorgio, Salvatore Marco, Diego Scardaci
Grid computing allows for the creation of e-infrastructures providing computational power and information storage capabilities needed both by... Sample PDF
Sustainable and Interoperable e-Infrastructures for Research and Business
$37.50
Chapter 3
Vassilikil Andronikou, Dimosthenis Kyriazis, Magdalini Kardara, Dimitrios Halkos, Theodora Varvarigou
The Grid has the potential to make a significant advance beyond the Internet, by turning it from a passive information medium into an active tool... Sample PDF
Scenarios of Next Generation Grid Applications in Collaborative EnvironmentsA Business-Technical Analysis
$37.50
Chapter 4
Gayathri Nadarajan, Areti Manataki, Yun-Heh Chen-Burger
The infrastructure of Grid is approaching maturity and can be used to enable the utilisation and sharing of large scale, remote data storages... Sample PDF
Semantics-Based Process Support for Grid Applications
$37.50
Chapter 5
Rogério Luís de Carvalho Costal, Pedro Furtado
The computational grid offers services for efficiently scheduling jobs on the grid, but for grid-enabled applications where data handling is a most... Sample PDF
Placement and Scheduling over Grid Warehouses
$37.50
Chapter 6
Navonil Mustafee, Simon J.E. Taylor
The computational grid offers services for efficiently scheduling jobs on the grid, but for grid-enabled applications where data handling is a most... Sample PDF
Leveraging Simulation Practice in Industry through use of Desktop Grid Middleware
$37.50
Chapter 7
Genoveffa Jeni Giambona, Nicholas L.J. Silburn, David W. Birchall
This chapter focuses on the collaborative use of computing resources to support decision making in industry. Through the use of middleware for... Sample PDF
Trust, Virtual Teams, and Grid Technology
$37.50
Chapter 8
Rob Smith, Rob Wilson
Flexible and remote working is becoming more and more widespread. In particular, virtual team working is growing rapidly. Although virtual teams... Sample PDF
The Socio-Technical Virtual Organisation
$37.50
Chapter 9
Marina Burakova-Lorgnier
A Virtual Organisation (VO) or Virtual Enterprise is a loosely-coupled group of collaborating organisations, acting to some extent as though they... Sample PDF
Modelling Trust–Control Dynamics for Grid-based Communities: A Shared Psychological Ownership Perspective
$37.50
Chapter 10
Lu Liu, Nick Antonopoulos
The aim of this chapter is to appreciate the need for and propose some thoughts on modelling trust–control dynamics for communities that use grid... Sample PDF
Small World Architecture for Building Effective Virtual Organisations
$37.50
Chapter 11
James Dooley, Andrea Zisman, George Spanoudakis
A Virtual Organisation in large-scale distributed systems is a set of individuals and/or institutions with some common purposes or interests that... Sample PDF
Runtime Service Discovery for Grid Applications
$37.50
Chapter 12
Nik Bessis
This chapter describes a framework to support runtime service discovery for Grid applications based on service discovery queries in both push and... Sample PDF
Model Architecture for a User Tailored Data Push Service in Data Grids
$37.50
Chapter 13
Eleana Asimakopoulou, Chimay J. Anumba, Bouchlaghem, Bouchlaghem
Much work is under way within the Grid technology community on issues associated with the development of services to foster collaboration via the... Sample PDF
Using Grid Technology for Maximizing Collaborative Emergency Response Decision Making
$37.50
Chapter 14
Ahmet Sayar, Geoffrey C. Fox, Marlon E. Pierce
Geographic information is critical for building disaster planning, crisis management, and early-warning systems. Decision making in geographic... Sample PDF
Unified Data Access/Query over Integrated Data-views for Decision Making in Geographic Information Systems
$37.50
About the Contributors