The Need for Identity Construction in Computer-Mediated Professional Communication: A Community of Practice Perspective

The Need for Identity Construction in Computer-Mediated Professional Communication: A Community of Practice Perspective

Victor Ho (The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hong Kong)
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-4666-2211-1.ch027
OnDemand PDF Download:


This chapter discusses the construction of personal identities by individuals of the same rank through the discourse they constructed while engaging in computer-mediated professional communication in the workplace. First, it discusses the need for the members of three different communities of practice to construct desirable personal identities via their daily computer-mediated professional communication. Second, it discusses how the members constructed these identities through the e-mail discourse they composed by exploiting various discursive strategies. Drawing upon systemic functional grammar, influence tactics, interdiscursivity, and rapport and rapport management, a total of 89 request e-mails were analyzed. The present study intends to bring to the fore the importance of the choice of language in professional communication in general, and in e-mail in particular, thereby enabling professionals to both encode and decode workplace communication in a more comprehensive manner.
Chapter Preview


The importance and salience of professional communication is noticeably evident when we consider the huge amount of research interest and scholarly discussion it has drawn in the last two decades (e.g. Sarangi & Roberts, 1999; Nickerson, 2002; Candlin & Hyland, 1999, Iedema & Scheeres, 2003). Among the many reasons why people – professionals, scholars and students (especially those who are entering into the workplace and those studying the English for Specific Purposes course or alike) – are paying so much attention to professional communication are, just to name a few, (1) communicative practices like talk and text are the thread which pull together the parts and parcels of workplaces since, according to Sarangi and Roberts (1999), “[w]orkplaces are held together by communicative practices” (p. 1); (2) one’s level of professionalism which is (or can be, at least) measured by one’s expert behavior is in turn measured by or reflected from one’s discursive competence (Candlin, 1999) manifested in one’s spoken and written communication; and (3) one’s communicative activity in the workplace, especially writing, is a “personal and socio-cultural act of identity” (Candlin & Hyland, 1999, p. 2), thereby enabling one to signal membership in the various “communities of practice” (Wenger, 1998) that one is a member of (ibid) on the one hand, and construct desirable personal identities in their communities of practice on the other (Ho, 2010a, 2010b).

The importance of professional communication in the workplace as just stipulated above is therefore two-fold – it serves not only a transactional function in conveying meanings, but also a relational or interpersonal function in helping practitioners demonstrate their professionalism and construct and manage desirable identities. These two functions, again as explained briefly just now, are performed and realized through discourse, writing in particular. It is therefore essential for professionals, as well as professionals-to-be, to have a thorough understanding of the role of (written) discourse in workplace communication between and among professionals. Writing in today’s world can be done in ways other than in the traditional pen-and-paper one. Word processing software saves practitioners of various fields a vast amount of time, and so does e-mailing. Research suggests that e-mail has become increasingly important in workplace communication. It is now one of the main communication channels in such professions as education (Wamser, 2003), healthcare (Goldner, 2006), law (Appleby, 2006), and business (Marinova et al., 2006). Such a popularity in the workplace makes it essential for one to first gain a clear understanding of the linguistics of e-mail, and second to make use of such linguistic knowledge in a way which can benefit oneself most in terms of the effectiveness of communication as well as the achievement of other personal aims like the construction of desirable identities (Candlin & Hyland, 1999; Ho, 2010a, 2010b).

Key Terms in this Chapter

Communities of Practice: “An aggregate of people who come together around mutual engagement in an endeavor. Ways of doing things, ways of talking, beliefs, values, power relations – in short, practices – emerge in the course of this mutual endeavor” (Eckert and McConnell-Ginet, 1992, p. 464).

Rapport and Rapport Management: “People’s subjective perceptions of (dis)harmony or smoothness-turbulence in interpersonal relations” (Spencer-Oatey and Franklin, 2009, p. 102). Rapport management refers to “the ways in which this (dis)harmony is (mis)managed” (ibid).

Request: An attempt by the e-mail author to get the recipient to perform an action required by the institutional, professional, and personal circumstances through evoking the recipient’s need for compliance on the grounds of institutional, professional, and personal motivators such as necessity, duty, and goodwill.

Interdiscursivity: ‘The use of elements in one discourse and social practice which carry institutional and social meanings from other discourses and social practices’ (Candlin and Maley, 1997, p. 212).

Professional Discourse: Discourse concerning “what the professionals routinely do as a way of accomplishing their duties and responsibilities” (Sarangi & Roberts, 1999, p. 15).

Personal Discourse: Discourse concerning the private sphere, or “lifeworld” (Habermas, 1984, p. 119) of the individuals.

Influence Tactics: Tactics that a requester uses in accompanying his/her request in order to increase the likelihood of request compliance by influencing the requestee.

Institutional Discourse: Discourse containing “features which are attributed to institutional practice, either manifestly or covertly, by professionals”, and is “characterized by rational, legitimate accounting practices which are authoritatively backed up by a set of rules and regulations governing an institution” (Sarangi & Roberts, 1999, p. 15).

Complete Chapter List

Search this Book:
List of Reviewers
Table of Contents
Rocci Luppicini
Chapter 1
Rocci Luppicini
Human identity and the meaning attached to being human have been shaped throughout human history by the entrenchment of new technologies and the... Sample PDF
The Emerging Field of Technoself Studies (TSS)
Chapter 2
Robert Andrew Dunn
Modern identity has been shaped by technology, which has in turn shaped theories in understanding identity. How one communicates who they are to... Sample PDF
Identity Theories and Technology
Chapter 3
Anna Croon Fors
This chapter is about the ontology of subjects in digitalization. Questions of ontology emerge as a response to contemporary concerns about the ways... Sample PDF
The Ontology of the Subject in Digitalization
Chapter 4
Federica Fornaciari
The goal of this chapter is to suggest theoretical means to address a fundamental question, what strategies do people use when presenting their... Sample PDF
The Language of Technoself: Storytelling, Symbolic Interactionism, and Online Identity
Chapter 5
Luciano L’Abate
This chapter attempts to define and clarify differences among paradigms, theories, and models in communication science according to a hierarchical... Sample PDF
Of Paradigms, Theories, and Models: A Conceptual Hierarchical Structure for Communication Science and Technoself
Chapter 6
Martine Rothblatt
Ethical issues arise with respect to a digitized analog of a person. Such an analog exists when a person transfers an adequate quantity of digitized... Sample PDF
Mindclone Technoselves: Multi-Substrate Legal Identities, Cyber-Psychology, and Biocyberethics
Chapter 7
Alessandro Tomasi
This chapter introduces, using a race as an allegory, three competing conceptions of man, or three ideals, in its relationship to technology, namely... Sample PDF
A Run for your [Techno]Self
Chapter 8
Stephen Marmura
Human identity, whether individual or collective, has always been conditioned by the mode(s) of communication dominant within any given society.... Sample PDF
The Mediation of Identity: Key Issues in Historic Perspective
Chapter 9
The Digital Soul  (pages 157-174)
Daniel Black
Contemporary understandings of the mind are seemingly free from the need for a soul of the kind imagined by Descartes. While for Descartes the soul... Sample PDF
The Digital Soul
Chapter 10
Samuel Wilson, Nick Haslam
Advances in bioscience and biotechnology move faster than our conceptual and ethical understanding of them. These advances may ultimately change... Sample PDF
Reasoning about Human Enhancement: Towards a Folk Psychological Model of Human Nature and Human Identity
Chapter 11
Ana-Cristina Ionescu
The realities of our world are imperatively legitimated by the complex relationship between media, technology, and society. Whether we deal with old... Sample PDF
Cyber Identity: Our Alter-Ego?
Chapter 12
Sara Konrath
The purpose of this chapter is to summarize changes in personality traits that have co-occurred with the rise of new social media, and to evaluate... Sample PDF
The Empathy Paradox: Increasing Disconnection in the Age of Increasing Connection
Chapter 13
Darren D. Chadwick, Chris Fullwood, Caroline J. Wesson
This chapter provides insight into the nature of online engagement by people with intellectual disabilities, the extent and quality of this... Sample PDF
Intellectual Disability, Identity, and the Internet
Chapter 14
Jesse Fox, Sun Joo Ahn
Avatars are defined as virtual representations that are controlled by a human user. Commonly, we observe avatars in video and online games, social... Sample PDF
Avatars: Portraying, Exploring, and Changing Online and Offline Identities
Chapter 15
Marlin Bates
In the rhetorical construction of identity, we are often tasked with analyzing how rhetoric either points to or creates a space for identity. This... Sample PDF
The Ur-Real Sonorous Envelope: Bridge between the Corporeal and the Online Technoself
Chapter 16
Nelly Elias
This chapter analyzes how the need to preserve ethnic identity and affiliation with one’s homeland is expressed and fulfilled through Internet use... Sample PDF
Immigrants’ Internet Use and Identity from an Intergenerational Perspective: Immigrant Senior Citizens and Youngsters from the Former Soviet Union in Israel
Chapter 17
William Sims Bainbridge
It is possible at the present time to create virtual representations of deceased loved ones, and inhabit them as a way of expressing reverence and... Sample PDF
Ancestor Veneration Avatars
Chapter 18
Rabindra Ratan
There is currently a need for a standardized concept that describes how relationships between the self and virtual self-representations operate... Sample PDF
Self-Presence, Explicated: Body, Emotion, and Identity Extension into the Virtual Self
Chapter 19
Sylvia Söderström
This chapter investigates the significance of assistive ICT as a tool in young disabled people’s identity negotiations. To analyse the impact of... Sample PDF
Assistive ICT and Young Disabled Persons: Opportunities and Obstacles in Identity Negotiations
Chapter 20
Fernando Andacht
This chapter studies the notion of technoself in a contemporary media phenomenon, reality television. How can we explain the attraction of the... Sample PDF
The Tangible Lure of the Technoself in the Age of Reality Television
Chapter 21
Antonio García-Gómez
This chapter examines social networking sites from a sociological and discursive perspective in order to highlight how users engage with them in the... Sample PDF
Technoself-Presentation on Social Networks: A Gender-Based Approach
Chapter 22
Chaka Chaka
This chapter seeks to explore the role played by mobile social networks (MoSoNets) in mediating and constituting, and in helping digitize and... Sample PDF
Digitization and Consumerization of Identity, Culture, and Power among Gen Mobinets in South Africa
Chapter 23
Jimmy Sanderson
This chapter explores how rookie athletes in Major League Baseball (MLB), the National Basketball Association (NBA), National Football League (NFL)... Sample PDF
Stepping into the (Social Media) Game: Building Athlete Identity via Twitter
Chapter 24
José Carlos Ribeiro, Tarcízio Silva
This chapter discusses the use of social applications in the process of the constitution of the self and the production of the self-presentation in... Sample PDF
Self, Self-Presentation, and the Use of Social Applications in Digital Environments
Chapter 25
Li Jin
The study of self-concept is essential in the fields of psychology, education, and for society in general, whilst self-concept is widely valued as a... Sample PDF
A New Trend in Education: Technoself Enhanced Social Learning
Chapter 26
Rachel Barker
The realisation that social networks in cyberspace create a different virtual setting where a Technoself can be created by the way an individual... Sample PDF
Social Networking and Identity
Chapter 27
Victor Ho
This chapter discusses the construction of personal identities by individuals of the same rank through the discourse they constructed while engaging... Sample PDF
The Need for Identity Construction in Computer-Mediated Professional Communication: A Community of Practice Perspective
Chapter 28
Jason Hawreliak
Winston Churchill famously asserted that “there is nothing more exhilarating than to be shot at without result.” Whether or not this is accurate, it... Sample PDF
“To Be Shot at Without Result”: Gaming and the Rhetoric of Immortality
Chapter 29
Derek McColl, Goldie Nejat
This chapter presents a real-time robust affect classification methodology for socially interactive robots engaging in one-on-one... Sample PDF
A Human Affect Recognition System for Socially Interactive Robots
Chapter 30
Francesc Ballesté, Carme Torras
Recent developments in social robotics, intelligent prosthetics, brain-computer interfaces, and implants pose new questions as to the effects of... Sample PDF
Effects of Human-Machine Integration on the Construction of Identity
Chapter 31
Gail F. Melson
This chapter focuses on how the technoself develops in children through relationships with a “personal” robot technology, robotic pets, especially... Sample PDF
Building a Technoself: Children’s Ideas about and Behavior toward Robotic Pets
Chapter 32
Julie Carpenter
This chapter provides a critical analysis of the potential short- and long-term cultural, emotional, and ethical outcomes facing Explosive Ordnance... Sample PDF
Just Doesn’t Look Right: Exploring the Impact of Humanoid Robot Integration into Explosive Ordnance Disposal Teams
Chapter 33
Fotios Papadopoulos, Kerstin Dautenhahn, Wan Ching Ho
This book chapter describes the implementation, testing, and evaluation of the first prototype of the “AIBOcom” system, which allows remote users to... Sample PDF
Behavioral Analysis of Human-Human Remote Social Interaction Mediated by an Interactive Robot in a Cooperative Game Scenario
Chapter 34
Kristi Scott
This chapter examines the cinematic representations of identity in Blade Runner, Bicentennial Man, and A.I. Artificial Intelligence. It looks at the... Sample PDF
The Human-Robot Continuum of Self: Where the Other Ends and Another Begins
Chapter 35
Yuji Sone
This chapter discusses Japanese roboticist Hiroshi Ishiguro’s performance experiments with robotic machines (humanoid and android) as a case study... Sample PDF
Robot Double: Hiroshi Ishiguro’s Reflexive Machines
Chapter 36
Erica Orange
The author presents an overview of how the ubiquitous nature of technology has led to a monumental shift in human evolution – a change involving... Sample PDF
Understanding the Human-Machine Interface in a Time of Change
Chapter 37
Marc A. Saner, Jeremy Geelen
This chapter provides a framework for the Technoself that distinguishes six different processes by which emerging technologies may affect human... Sample PDF
Identity in a Technological Society: Governance Implications
About the Contributors