The Politics of the Governing the Information and Communications Technologies in East Asian Authoritarian States: Case Study of China

The Politics of the Governing the Information and Communications Technologies in East Asian Authoritarian States: Case Study of China

Chin-fu Hung (National Cheng Kung University, Taiwan)
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60566-254-1.ch009
OnDemand PDF Download:


China has vigorously implemented ICTs to foster ongoing informatization accompanying industrialization as a crucial pillar to drive its future economic development. The institutional and legal reforms involved were initiated and put into practice in order to meet the increasing demand for technological convergence and the negotiations for the expected entry into the World Trade Organization (WTO). The Chinese government has nevertheless long been torn by the ambivalence brought about by the Internet. It regards the Internet as an engine to drive economic growth on the one hand, and as a subversive challenge to undermine the ruling Communist Party on the other hand. As soon as ICTs were introduced and Web sites mushroomed, the Party was so determined to harness the new medium to assure the Internet’s economic and scientific benefits. As a consequence, controls other than stifling ICTs would be critical for the CCP’s agenda to achieve the century-long modernization process and in the meantime, consolidate its power.
Chapter Preview

…if information technology is the present-day equivalent of electricity in the industrial era, in our age the Internet could be likened to both the electrical grid and the electric engine because of its ability to distribute the power of information throughout the entire realm of human activity (Castells 2001: 1).

It is usually believed that “authoritarian systems are inherently fragile because of weak legitimacy, overreliance on coercion, overcentralization of decision making, and the predominance of personal power over institutional norms.” (Nathan 2003: 6) Yet, Shanthi Kalathil and Taylor Boas reject the idea of “blind optimism” about the Internet, suggesting that the Internet may not necessarily transform authoritarian regime. The new media may instead be exploited by the authorities there as an effective tool to further strengthen their governing capability in the information age (Kalathil and Boas 2003). Similarly Nina Hachigian holds one-party states who embrace the Internet are not more likely to fail than those that attempt to constrain the medium (Hachigian 2001, 2002). This chapter does not, however, suggest that (new) technology absolutely determines social activity, nor does the realm of society and politics condition the entire course of technological change. Instead, it is likely to be a two-way interaction between the technology and sociopolitical development.

In the Chinese context, as China is gearing up to transform its economy from central planning into one of the world’s key IT-driven economies, it provides a crucial test case for other like-minded regimes—Vietnam and North Korea, particularly—as to the ways in which governments may handle the threat or grasp the economic opportunities from cyberspace. As Hu Angang, a renowned Chinese scholar who is close to the central leaders in Beijing, enthusiastically holds, China, under economic globalization, ought to adopt the knowledge-driven strategy as its most significant national development approach in the twenty-first century. He explains that the application of ICTs can not only “bridge the divide between China and developed countries in terms of knowledge development, but also shrink the digital gap between hinterland and coastal China.” (Hu 2002: 15)

The Chinese government has no doubt acted as a vital driving force for boosting Internet and e-commerce diffusion. In retrospect, from March 1993 the Chinese central government embarked upon a series of so-called “Golden Projects”1—including Golden Bridge, Golden Card, and Golden Customs—to give it information on and control over the rapid decentralization of decision-making that was taking place as a result of the move towards a market economy. The year 1993 can also be remembered as the formal start-up stage of China’s informatization. (Lu 2002: 53) On the one hand, this was aimed at laying the infrastructure for the digitization of China’s telecommunications network, on the other hand, the central government started indeed to utilize the infrastructure of the Internet to improve its own administrative control over provincial and local offices, enhancing its governing capacity and authority, as well as sociopolitical stability. In November 1998 the authorities further announced the “Government Online Project” whereby the end of 1999 and 2000, at least 60 and 80 percent respectively of China’s government offices and ministries were going online: all ministries and provincial authorities would establish their own Web sites for citizens to consult.2 China even christened 1999 “The Government Online Year” (People’s Daily, 3 January 1999) and 2000 the year of Enterprise Online Project.”3

To date, Internet access has been expanding rapidly and extensively chiefly due to direct support and promotion by the government. As we may examine in the recent semi-annual survey report on the development of China’s Internet, released by the quasi-official China Internet Network Information Center, also known as CNNIC, the estimated total number of Internet users by the end of December 2008 was more than 298 million, the world’s largest Internet market that has surpassed the United States since June 2008.4 The overall Internet penetration rate in China has also reached up to 22.6 percent.5 Anyhow, such an amazing achievement within a relatively short period of time coincides with Dali Yang’s observation that, although China is a latecomer to the Internet world, the government can act swiftly to play a key part in unleashing the Internet’s economic potential (Yang 2001: 65). Table 1 illustrates this.

Complete Chapter List

Search this Book:
Editorial Advisory Board
Table of Contents
Francesco Amoretti
Chapter 1
Francesco Amoretti
In “Electronic Constitution: A Braudelian Perspective”, Francesco Amoretti presents a model for the analysis of time and space structures of digital... Sample PDF
Electronic Constitution: A Braudelian Perspective
Chapter 2
Mauro Di Meglio, Enrico Gargiulo
This chapter offers a long-term perspective on citizenship, questioning one of the basic assumptions of most of the literature on this topic, that... Sample PDF
Old and New Rights: E-Citizenship in Historical Perspective
Chapter 3
Oreste Ventrone
Following the diffusion of e-government in the high income countries, international organizations, notably UN, OECD, World Bank, have promoted the... Sample PDF
International Organizations, E-Government and Development
Chapter 4
Fortunato Musella
The chapter is dedicated at analyzing the strategic use of new technologies in the United States. An evident synergy has been noted between the... Sample PDF
American Electronic Constitution: Reinventing Government and Neo-Liberal Corporatism
Chapter 5
Francesco Amoretti, Fortunato Musella
The challenge of convergence has become a core issue in the European agenda, as the existence of widely accepted administrative standards represents... Sample PDF
The European Administrative Space and E-Government Policies: Between Integration and Competition
Chapter 6
Clementina Casula
The rhetoric used worldwide by policymakers in promoting the uptake of Information and Communication Technologies (ICT) emphasizes the advantages... Sample PDF
The EU and the Information Society: From E-Knowledge to E-Inclusion, in Search of Global Leadership
Chapter 7
Nicolas Pejout
Many of African States are focusing on ICTs and developing e-government infrastructures in order to fasten and improve their “formalisation... Sample PDF
World Wide Weber: Formalise, Normalise, Rationalise
Chapter 8
Joseph Ofori-Dankwa, Connie Ofori-Dankwa
Several African countries have begun to introduce and implement Information and Communication Technology (ICT) policies. In the context of such... Sample PDF
ICT Challenges and Opportunities for Institutionalizing Democracy in Ghana: An Integrative Review of the Literature
Chapter 9
Chin-fu Hung
China has vigorously implemented ICTs to foster ongoing informatization accompanying industrialization as a crucial pillar to drive its future... Sample PDF
The Politics of the Governing the Information and Communications Technologies in East Asian Authoritarian States: Case Study of China
Chapter 10
Claudia Padovani, Elena Pavan
Political processes are undergoing profound changes due to the challenges imposed by globalization processes to the legitimacy of policy actors and... Sample PDF
Information Networks, Internet Governance and Innovation in World Politics
Chapter 11
Mauro Santaniello
The Internet Governance debate has, for a long time, been influenced by a well-defined characterization of information networks. The depiction of a... Sample PDF
Who Governs Cyberspace? Internet Governance and Power Structures in Digital Networks
Chapter 12
Diego Giannone
Starting from the assumption that any technology embeds the ideology, politics and culture of the society where it was created, this chapter... Sample PDF
Measuring ICT: Political and Methodological Aspects
Chapter 13
Paolo Landri
This chapter is dedicated to analyse the fabrication of networked socialities, that is to address the complex interweaving of technologies of... Sample PDF
The Fabrication of Networked Socialities
Chapter 14
Virtual Nations  (pages 224-241)
William Sims Bainbridge
Virtual worlds are computer environments in which large numbers of human beings may interact, do useful work for each others, and build enduring... Sample PDF
Virtual Nations
Chapter 15
Francesco Amoretti
This volume does not constitute yet another account of the blessings of ICTs. Nor does it add new criticism to the old, nurturing fears about the... Sample PDF
A Research Agenda for the Future
About the Contributors