Question Answering Using Word Associations

Question Answering Using Word Associations

Ganesh Ramakrishnan (IBM India Research Labs, India) and Pushpak Bhattacharyya (IIT Bombay, India)
Copyright: © 2009 |Pages: 33
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-59904-990-8.ch033
OnDemand PDF Download:


Text mining systems such as categorizers and query retrievers of the first generation were largely hinged on word level statistics and provided a wonderful first-cut approach. However systems based on simple word-level statistics quickly saturate in performance, despite the best data mining and machine learning algorithms. This problem can be traced to the fact that, typically, naive, word-based feature representations are used in text applications, which prove insufficient in bridging two types of chasms within and across documents, viz. lexical chasm and syntactic chasm . The latest wave in text mining technology has been marked by research that will make extraction of subtleties from the underlying meaning of text, a possibility. In the following two chapters, we pose the problem of underlying meaning extraction from text documents, coupled with world knowledge, as a problem of bridging the chasms by exploiting associations between entities. The entities are words or word collocations from documents. We utilize two types of entity associations, viz. paradigmatic (PA) and syntagmatic (SA). We present first-tier algorithms that use these two word associations in bridging the syntactic and lexical chasms. We also propose second-tier algorithms in two sample applications, viz., question answering and text classification which use the first-tier algorithms. Our contribution lies in the specific methods we introduce for exploiting entity association information present in WordNet, dictionaries, corpora and parse trees for improved performance in text mining applications.
Chapter Preview

1. Introduction

A QA system responds to queries like Who is the Greek God of the sea? with a precise answer like Poseidon. A slightly less ambitious goal is to identify short snippets or passages of up to several words which contain the answer.

QA has roots in classic AI-style inference engines, but in this work we focus on recent open-domain systems closer to the Information Retrieval (IR) community. Falcon Harabagiu et aI., 2000a), Webclopedia (Hovy et aI., 2000), AnswerBus (Zheng,2002) and AskMSR (Dumais et al., 2002) are some well-known research systems, as are those built at the University of Waterloo (Clarke et al., 2000; Clarke et al., 200lb), and Ask Jeeves (

Most QA systems are substantial team efforts, involving the design and maintenance of question taxonomies, question classifiers, and passage scoring heuristics. The intensity of human effort involved has limited state-of-the-art QA system development to a handful of groups. The current lack of clear separation between algorithms and knowledge bases makes it hard to gage the benefits of new algorithmic ideas, and to generalize the tuning experience to new domains, new corpora, and new languages.

The description of a QA system is almost exclusively about how questions and passages are processed, how they are matched and scored, and how external knowledge bases (question taxonomy, dictionary, and thesauri) are exploited. Even if some strategies make intuitive sense, the treatment is predominantly operational (how) rather than declarative (what): it is rare to find a system-independent discussion of general properties that make one passage better answer a question than another.

Compare the QA situation with IR engines, which are available off the shelf (e.g., Lucene (Group, 2002)), require essentially no tuning, and can be deployed in minutes. The basics of the vector space model and tfidf ranking can be taught in an hour. In contrast, QA systems contain large pieces of software, lashed together in diverse ways with customized “glue” and many crucial knobs to turn. Naturally, these knobs are best turned by QA specialists rather than the end-user, which might explain in part why off-the-shelf QA packages are rare.

The broad architecture of QA systems (Clarke et aI., 2000; Harabagiu et aI., 2000a; Hovy et al., 2000; Zheng, 2002; Clarke et al., 2001b; Radev et aI., 2002) has become standard. The corpus is indexed at the level of documents or passages chopped-up at a suitable size. A shallow entity extractor, supported by a large gazette, is sometimes run on the passages to identify people, places, organizations, etc. (Abney et al., 2000; Dill et aI., 2003), which may also be indexed. A taxonomy of question types (where, when, who, how many, etc.) is built by hand, and rules tuned to map questions to types. Several QA systems assume that an answer type catalog is available. And if it is not already available, they build such catalogs with great care (Harabagiu et aI., 2000b; Hovy et al., 2000) and classify each question into an answer type. Accordingly, the question is transformed into a keyword query to be submitted to the index. Responding passages are re-ranked using a variety of strategies.

Key Terms in this Chapter

Selector: A word in a question that is a ground constant and expected to appear as it is in an answer passage.

Focus Word: The word in ‘what’, ‘which’ and ‘name’ type of questions that specifies what the type of the answer should be.

NsySQLQA: A question answering technique that recovers from the question, fragments of what might have been posed as a structured query (SQL), and extracts answer passages based on these fragments (Section §1.3.1).

BayesWN: Construction of a Bayesian Network from WordNet lexical relations and training of the Bayesian Network in a semi-supervised manner from raw text.

BayesQA: Question Answering using Bayesian Inferencing on Lexical relations (Section §1.2) using the Bayesian Network Model BayesWN.

Complete Chapter List

Search this Book:
Editorial Advisory Board
Table of Contents
Xiaohua Hu
Min Song, Yi-Fang Brook Wu
Min Song, Yi-Fang Brook Wu
Chapter 1
Ying Liu
In the automated text classification, a bag-of-words representation followed by the tfidf weighting is the most popular approach to convert the... Sample PDF
On Document Representation and Term Weights in Text Classification
Chapter 2
Yi-fang Brook Wu, Quanzhi Li
Document keyphrases provide semantic metadata which can characterize documents and produce an overview of the content of a document. This chapter... Sample PDF
Deriving Document Keyphrases for Text Mining
Chapter 3
John Atkinson
This chapter introduces a novel evolutionary model for intelligent text mining. The model deals with issues concerning shallow text representation... Sample PDF
Intelligent Text Mining: Putting Evolutionary Methods and Language Technologies Together
Chapter 4
Xiaoyan Yu, Manas Tungare, Weigo Yuan, Yubo Yuan, Manuel Pérez-Quiñones, Edward A. Fox
Syllabi are important educational resources. Gathering syllabi that are freely available and creating useful services on top of the collection... Sample PDF
Automatic Syllabus Classification Using Support Vector Machines
Chapter 5
Xiao-Li Li
In traditional text categorization, a classifier is built using labeled training documents from a set of predefined classes. This chapter studies a... Sample PDF
Partially Supervised Text Categorization
Chapter 6
Yu-Jin Zhang
Mining techniques can play an important role in automatic image classification and content-based retrieval. A novel method for image classification... Sample PDF
Image Classification and Retrieval with Mining Technologies
Chapter 7
Han-joon Kim
This chapter introduces two practical techniques for improving Naïve Bayes text classifiers that are widely used for text classification. The Naïve... Sample PDF
Improving Techniques for Naïve Bayes Text Classifiers
Chapter 8
Ricco Rakotomalala, Faouzi Mhamdi
In this chapter, we are interested in proteins classification starting from their primary structures. The goal is to automatically affect proteins... Sample PDF
Using the Text Categorization Framework for Protein Classification
Chapter 9
Wilson Wong
Feature-based semantic measurements have played a dominant role in conventional data clustering algorithms for many existing applications. However... Sample PDF
Featureless Data Clustering
Chapter 10
Xiaohui Cui
In this chapter, we introduce three nature inspired swarm intelligence clustering approaches for document clustering analysis. The major challenge... Sample PDF
Swarm Intelligence in Text Document Clustering
Chapter 11
P. Viswanth
Clustering is a process of finding natural grouping present in a dataset. Various clustering methods are proposed to work with various types of... Sample PDF
Some Efficient and Fast Approaches to Document Clustering
Chapter 12
Abdelmalek Amine, Zakaria Elberrichi, Michel Simonet, Ladjel Bellatreche, Mimoun Malki
The classification of textual documents has been the subject of many studies. Technologies like the Web and numerical libraries facilitated the... Sample PDF
SOM-Based Clustering of Textual Documents Using WordNet
Chapter 13
Lean Yu, Shouyang Wang, Kin Keung Lai
With the rapid increase of the huge amount of online information, there is a strong demand for Web text mining which helps people discover some... Sample PDF
A Multi-Agent Neural Network System for Web Text Mining
Chapter 14
Sangeetha Kutty
With the emergence of XML standardization, XML documents have been widely used and accepted in almost all the major industries. As a result of the... Sample PDF
Frequent Mining on XML Documents
Chapter 15
Richi Nayak
XML has gained popularity for information representation, exchange and retrieval. As XML material becomes more abundant, its heterogeneity and... Sample PDF
The Process and Application of XML Data Mining
Chapter 16
Francesco Buccafurri
In the context of Knowledge Discovery in Databases, data reduction is a pre-processing step delivering succinct yet meaningful data to sequent... Sample PDF
Approximate Range Querying over Sliding Windows
Chapter 17
Jan H. Kroeze
This chapter discusses the application of some data warehousing techniques on a data cube of linguistic data. The results of various modules of... Sample PDF
Slicing and Dicing a Linguistic Data Cube
Chapter 18
Yi-fang Brook Wu, Xin Chen
This chapter presents a methodology for personalized knowledge discovery from text. Traditionally, problems with text mining are numerous rules... Sample PDF
Discovering Personalized Novel Knowledge from Text
Chapter 19
Catia Pesquita
Biomedical research generates a vast amount of information that is ultimately stored in scientific publications or in databases. The information in... Sample PDF
Untangling BioOntologies for Mining Biomedical Information
Chapter 20
Luis M. de Campos
In this chapter, we present a thesaurus application in the field of text mining and more specifically automatic indexing on the set of descriptors... Sample PDF
Thesaurus-Based Automatic Indexing
Chapter 21
Concept-Based Text Mining  (pages 346-358)
Stanley Loh, Leandro Krug Wives, Daniel Lichtnow, José Palazzo M. de Oliveira
The goal of this chapter is to present an approach to mine texts through the analysis of higher level characteristics (called “concepts’)... Sample PDF
Concept-Based Text Mining
Chapter 22
Marcello Pecoraro
This chapter aims at providing an overview about the use of statistical methods supporting the Web Usage Mining. Within the first part is described... Sample PDF
Statistical Methods for User Profiling in Web Usage Mining
Chapter 23
Quanzhi Li, Yi-fang Brook Wu
This chapter presents a new approach of mining the Web to identify people of similar background. To find similar people from the Web for a given... Sample PDF
Web Mining to Identify People of Similar Background
Chapter 24
Pawan Lingras
This chapter describes how Web usage patterns can be used to improve the navigational structure of a Web site. The discussion begins with an... Sample PDF
Hyperlink Structure Inspired by Web Usage
Chapter 25
Rosa Meo, Maristella Matera
In this chapter, we present the usage of a modeling language, WebML, for the design and the management of dynamic Web applications. WebML also makes... Sample PDF
Designing and Mining Web Applications: A Conceptual Modeling Approach
Chapter 26
Brigitte Trousse, Marie-Aude Aufaure, Bénédicte Le Grand, Yves Lechevallier, Florent Masseglia
This chapter proposes an original approach for ontology management in the context of Web-based information systems. Our approach relies on the usage... Sample PDF
Web Usage Mining for Ontology Management
Chapter 27
Yue-Shi Lee
Web mining is one of the mining technologies, which applies data mining techniques in large amounts of Web data to improve the Web services. Web... Sample PDF
A Lattice-Based Framework for Interactively and Incrementally Mining Web Traversal Patterns
Chapter 28
Stanley R.M. Oliveira, Osmar R. Zaïane
Privacy-preserving data mining (PPDM) is one of the newest trends in privacy and security research. It is driven by one of the major policy issues... Sample PDF
Privacy-Preserving Data Mining on the Web: Foundations and Techniques
Chapter 29
G.S. Mahalakshmi, S. Sendhilkumar
Automatic reference tracking involves systematic tracking of reference articles listed for a particular research paper by extracting the references... Sample PDF
Automatic Reference Tracking
Chapter 30
Wilson Wong
As more electronic text is readily available, and more applications become knowledge intensive and ontology-enabled, term extraction, also known as... Sample PDF
Determination of Unithood and Termhood for Term Recognition
Chapter 31
Fotis Lazarinis
Over 60% of the online population are non-English speakers and it is probable the number of non-English speakers is growing faster than English... Sample PDF
Retrieving Non-Latin Information in a Latin Web: The Case of Greek
Chapter 32
Anne Kao
Latent Semantic Analysis (LSA) or Latent Semantic Indexing (LSI), when applied to information retrieval, has been a major analysis approach in text... Sample PDF
Latent Semantic Analysis and Beyond
Chapter 33
Ganesh Ramakrishnan, Pushpak Bhattacharyya
Text mining systems such as categorizers and query retrievers of the first generation were largely hinged on word level statistics and provided a... Sample PDF
Question Answering Using Word Associations
Chapter 34
Giuseppe Manco, Riccardo Ortale, Andrea Tagarelli
Personalization is aimed at adapting content delivery to users’ profiles: namely, their expectations, preferences and requirements. This chapter... Sample PDF
The Scent of a Newsgroup: Providing Personalized Access to Usenet Sites through Web Mining
Chapter 35
Alexander Dreweke, Ingrid Fischer, Tobias Werth, Marc Wörlein
Searching for frequent pieces in a database with some sort of text is a well-known problem. A special sort of text is program code as e.g. C++ or... Sample PDF
Text Mining in Program Code
Chapter 36
Nitin Agarwal, Huan Liu, Jianping Zhang
In Golbeck and Hendler (2006), authors consider those social friendship networking sites where users explicitly provide trust ratings to other... Sample PDF
A Study of Friendship Networks and Blogosphere
Chapter 37
Pasquale De Meo
In this chapter we present an information system conceived for supporting managers of Public Health Care Agencies to decide the new health care... Sample PDF
An HL7-Aware Decision Support System for E-Health
Chapter 38
Diego Liberati
Building effective multitarget classifiers is still an on-going research issue: this chapter proposes the use of the knowledge gleaned from a human... Sample PDF
Multitarget Classifiers for Mining in Bioinformatics
Chapter 39
Shuting Xu
Text mining is an instrumental technology that today’s organizations can employ to extract information and further evolve and create valuable... Sample PDF
Current Issues and Future Analysis in Text Mining for Information Security Applications
Chapter 40
E. Thirumaran
This chapter introduces Collaborative filtering-based recommendation systems, which has become an integral part of E-commerce applications, as can... Sample PDF
Collaborative Filtering Based Recommendation Systems
Chapter 41
Hanna Suominen
The purpose of this chapter is to provide an overview of prevalent measures for evaluating the quality of system output in seven key text mining... Sample PDF
Performance Evaluation Measures for Text Mining
Chapter 42
Yanliang Qi
The biology literatures have been increased in an exponential growth in recent year. The researchers need an effective tool to help them find out... Sample PDF
Text Mining in Bioinformatics: Research and Application
Chapter 43
Ki Jung Lee
With the increased use of Internet, a large number of consumers first consult on line resources for their healthcare decisions. The problem of the... Sample PDF
Literature Review in Computational Linguistics Issues in the Developing Field of Consumer Informatics: Finding the Right Information for Consumer's Health Information Need
Chapter 44
Richard S. Segall
This chapter presents background on text mining, and comparisons and summaries of seven selected software for text mining. The text mining software... Sample PDF
A Survey of Selected Software Technologies for Text Mining
Chapter 45
Ah Chung Tsoi, Phuong Kim To, Markus Hagenbuchner
This chapter describes the application of a number of text mining techniques to discover patterns in the health insurance schedule with an aim to... Sample PDF
Application of Text Mining Methodologies to Health Insurance Schedules
Chapter 46
Miao-Ling Wang, Hsiao-Fan Wang
With the ever-increasing and ever-changing flow of information available on the Web, information analysis has never been more important. Web text... Sample PDF
Web Mining System for Mobile-Phone Marketing
Chapter 47
Neil Davis
Text mining technology can be used to assist in finding relevant or novel information in large volumes of unstructured data, such as that which is... Sample PDF
Web Service Architectures for Text Mining: An Exploration of the Issues via an E-Science Demonstrator
About the Editors
About the Contributors