In this chapter, we start analyzing an entire sector (the brokerage service sector) rather than one particular business organization in order to understand the case studies. The reason for using the entire sector as the unit of analysis is that the e-service problems and challenges are similar for the entire sector and is not unique to one organization alone (see next section, which discusses the problem of this sector). More so, the best way to illustrate e-service innovations of online brokers, we need to relate their unique e-service solutions to the problem facing the entire sector.
E-service in this chapter is defined as the service provided by electronic brokerage systems used to facilitate the buying and selling of publicly-traded corporate stocks and financial securities online. If you want to own/buy shares of stocks in companies like Microsoft or IBM, you can trade their shares electronically through e-brokerage systems like Scottrade, E-Trade, and Ameritrade. By trading shares online, you are using an electronic service similar to an online auction system, where sellers and buyers bid for the prices of different stocks and financial securities. Buyers want to get the cheapest prices and sellers want to sell at the highest prices, and the electronic trading systems helps them with that objective – this is a critical e-service for the trillion-dollar global financial market, where stocks, futures, options, bonds, foreign exchange and commodities are traded daily. These electronic brokers do not necessarily own stocks or financial securities. They process the orders electronically by channeling the orders through different networked financial market systems via the New York Stock Exchange, the London Stock Exchange, the Shanghai Stock Exchange and many other stock exchanges around the world.
Another critical e-service that needs to be defined is the service that assists online investors and traders make informed decisions whether to buy or sell stocks and when to execute such trade. E-brokers provide bundled e-services like real-time news reports, real-time charting of stock price movements, the demand and supply of stocks, stock analyst ratings, and research on the company’s financial health. This is how different e-services are “bundled” to help facilitate critical decisions in electronic financial markets. Different information systems, software applications, real-time databases, and networking technologies are used in the bundling of e-services.
In previous studies (Yap and Lin, 2001), the transaction capabilities of online trading systems as well as their knowledge-based components have been explored. These studies showed that earlier web-based trading systems took one to three minutes to execute market orders; whereas, more current systems can execute orders in one to three seconds. Transaction speed is not the real issue anymore. The real concern is whether traders are getting the “best price” for their trade executions. The demand for financial research and knowledge-base services online also needs to be more innovative to distinguish the uniqueness of e-services provided by different e-brokers. So the issue is what more can e-brokers provide their clients? In what areas can e-service innovation take place in the online brokerage sector? To get an idea of where innovation needs to happen, the problems of the online brokerage sector needs to be defined. Only then can we see how innovations in technologies and its bundling can provide solutions to such problems.
Defining the Problem in the Online Brokerage Sector
The problems with the electronic services provided by most online brokerage outfits are threefold. (1) Not all systems comply with the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Trading Requirements (rules and regulations) - Most information systems used for financial trading have loopholes in terms of preventing traders and investors from breaking SEC rules and US government laws. This is important because many amateur traders are not familiar with laws governing the trading of financial instruments in US financial markets. Breaking the law could be very costly and may prevent a trader from trading stocks again. This is a very serious problem not adequately addressed by e-service systems in the brokerage sector. (2) There is a need to connect fragmented financial electronic markets to reflect more realistic stock quotes. There are financial e-trading systems that are not as broadly networked to different financial electronic markets as other systems. This means that if your online brokerage service is only connected or bundled to two electronic financial markets while another online brokerage service is bundled to eight electronic financial markets, then your online broker’s system may not be able to get you the best “buy” and “sell” price for your stocks like the more connected/networked e-brokers can. Many traders have complained that their orders were not executed at the price they wanted, even if they saw that their stocks momentarily hit those price ranges. This happens when an online trading system is only connected to a few electronic markets. (3) Problem with Systems Stability and Reliability - Some online brokerage systems are not very stable and reliable, and therefore disrupting e-service more often during the electronic trading process. This is also a very serious problem. Imagine if your stock went down from $21.50 to $17.63 and you could not sell it because your online broker’s system was down for three hours. One of the purposes of this study is to test some of the more popular trading systems for more than a year and see how they hold up over time.
This research employs the ‘case research’ methodology. The researchers were involved in the actual use of the financial trading system and so data was acquired on a first-hand basis. The research uses the interpretive approach, which is essentially based on the unique experience of the user. The researchers gather the findings from direct experience and day-to-day interaction with the trading systems, its inherent technological features, and the customer support provided by the e-broker when the system is not working properly.
To be able to do an in-depth analysis, the researchers opened four (4) separate accounts so that four different popular e-trading systems can be tested and compared. However, due to limited space in writing this chapter, we can only cover two cases discussing two different e-trading systems. The two cases chosen for this chapter offered the more innovative e-services in the industry at the time of data gathering. Each e-trading system was used for more than a year. More than fifty trades were conducted on each system, with a frequency of at least once each week. Several systems features were explored to see what value it provided the user. Trading online naturally meant that the researchers acquired their information/data first hand. To validate and confirm some findings, the researchers also engage in dialogues with trading communities through message boards with user reviews.