‘Stacked' Actor-Networks and Their Computer Modelling: The Problem of Identity

‘Stacked' Actor-Networks and Their Computer Modelling: The Problem of Identity

Peter Kopanov (University of Plovdiv, Faculty of Mathematics and Informatics, Plovdiv, Bulgaria) and Ivan Tchalakov (University of Plovdiv, Faculty of Philosophy and History, Plovdiv, Bulgaria)
DOI: 10.4018/IJANTTI.2016100104
OnDemand PDF Download:


The paper dev?lops the mathematical basis of stacked actor-network (SAN) approach in modeling a socio-economic and cultural dynamics. It attempts to avoid the idea of ‘guidance' of a given form of (social) life being modelled, which has long been dominating in traditional sociology. Using methods of discreet mathematics and stochastic finite automata approach, we provided initial mathematical formalization of agent and actor-network, the types of complexity in the actor-network and three basic types of graphs comprising SAN's minimal model, with further aim is to develop these models in the form of computer programs (software) and to test them on real sociological data.
Article Preview


In previously published papers (Kopanov, Tchalakov, Keskinova, 2010) we formulated the main principles in modelling the behavior a specific type of actor-networks we called ‘stacked actor-networks’ (SAN). There one and the same actors are simultaneously present in several actor-networks under different ‘identities’. Studying given economy, for example, we can find the same companies and organizations interacting in a set of corporate interlocking directorates, and then a being shared between the same set owners, and also located in close geographical proximity, etc., thus “…each company serving as a node that allow you to make sense of how all these networks are stacked together” (Muniesa & Tchalakov, 2012, p. 15).

The stacked network model aims at describing the processes and interactions in this specific type of actor-networks and possibly at predicting (or rather ‘understanding’, at least qualitatively) their behavior. It also allows accounting for the heterogeneity of actor-networks, using specific stochastic automata to model not only human individual or corporate agents, but also technologies, artefacts, money, and so forth.

This paper continues the efforts presented in the two papers cited above, focusing on the key problem of how to account for different identities of one and the same actor in the different SANs, providing an initial outline of the necessary steps towards its formalization. We will begin with the brief discussion about the very possibility to build a formal model that mimics sufficiently enough the behavior of a real actor-network. We mean formal (mathematical) modelling of SAN which, with given inputs, generates output data that correspond to those generated by real-world agents in an actual actor-network. There are two options in this modelling: first, if actual outputs are determined, the models must also be determined and match the real ones; and second - if the actual outputs are stochastic, those in the model must also be stochastic, so that the initial distributions of the real agents and the models should be the same in the framework of the statistical test.

It is important to note that we are aiming at a model that rather mimic SANs functionally, and not so much as structure – in fact we mean specific realization of Turing's famous test proving the presence of intelligence.1 In it, the examiner carries out a natural language conversation with another person and with the machine being tested (both man and the machine are presented as people), asking them questions and receiving answers without having direct contact with them. If during the conversation tester cannot determine with certainty which of his interlocutors is a machine and who is a man, then it must be admitted that the machine imparts intelligence to a person (whatever that may be).

From what has been said, it follows that the answer to the question posed at the beginning about the possibility of building a formal model of agent behavior in the network is positive not only in principle. These specific examples show that creating an adequate model of a network of human and non-human actors is a difficult but realistic goal accessible to modern standard computer systems.

These considerations allow us to modify the above-mentioned goal of the study in the following way: modeling network operators in such a way that an outside observer cannot distinguish their “playing” behavior from that of any real “players”.

Complete Article List

Search this Journal:
Open Access Articles: Forthcoming
Volume 9: 4 Issues (2017): 1 Released, 3 Forthcoming
Volume 8: 4 Issues (2016)
Volume 7: 4 Issues (2015)
Volume 6: 4 Issues (2014)
Volume 5: 4 Issues (2013)
Volume 4: 4 Issues (2012)
Volume 3: 4 Issues (2011)
Volume 2: 4 Issues (2010)
Volume 1: 4 Issues (2009)
View Complete Journal Contents Listing