Economic Concepts, Methods, and Tools for Risk Analysis in Forestry under Climate Change

Economic Concepts, Methods, and Tools for Risk Analysis in Forestry under Climate Change

Tim B. Williamson (Canadian Forest Service, Canada), Grant K. Hauer (University of Alberta, Canada) and M. K.(Marty) Luckert (University of Alberta, Canada)
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60960-156-0.ch015
OnDemand PDF Download:
List Price: $37.50


Climate change will affect the expected values and distributions of key variables that influence forest management decisions. Risk analysis will likely play a more prominent role in forestry decision making. There are, however, different types of risk problems and different types of models and approaches to choose from. Three possible models that could have application in a climate change risk context are: (1) the Markowitz Portfolio Frontier Model; (2) Expected Value-variance/Chance Constraint Hybrid Model; (3) Discrete Stochastic Programming. These models are applicable in different contexts and answer different questions. For example, the Markowitz model looks for the asset mix that minimizes portfolio variance subject to a minimum expected return. The expected value-variance/chance constraint model accounts for risk preferences and uncertainty in both objective function and constraints variables. The objective function is to maximize certainty equivalent. The discrete stochastic programming model allows for learning to occur and for the decision maker to modify his/her decisions as new information becomes available over a planning horizon.
Chapter Preview

Climate Change And Forests

There is a growing body of scientific evidence that the earth’s climate is changing and that these changes are at least in part due to human activities such as burning of fossil fuels and land-use changes. The IPCC reports that there has been an estimated 0.74 ° C (± 0.18 ° C) increase in mean global temperature over the period 1906-2005 (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change 2007). On the basis of scenario projections of atmospheric greenhouse gas concentrations, general circulation models suggest that mean global temperature could increase by a further 1.8 ° C to 4.0 ° C by 2090. In northern countries such as Canada, temperature increases are expected to be even more pronounced (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change 2007).

Trees and forests are sensitive to climate. Relatively small changes in ambient climate can have significant impacts on forests in particular locales. The rate of climate change that is expected to occur over the next century will likely exceed naturally occurring rates of climate change. Climatic regimes in particular locales could shift at rates that may exceed the ability of some tree species to migrate in response to climate change or adapt or tolerate the changes in situ (Johnston et al., 2009). Climate change may, therefore, affect the distribution, health, composition and productivity of trees and forests (Williamson et al., 2009). However, there is uncertainty about the direction, timing and magnitude of future impacts on forests and ultimately on forest management at specific locations. One thing is certain. Deterministic predictions of future productivity, survival and species distributions based on historical observation may not provide a useful basis for predictions. These variables are, however, important for long term forest planning, yield estimation and timber supply analysis. Other types of approaches such as modeling, scenario development or solicitation of expert knowledge will be needed. However, the predicted values that result from these approaches will be random and subject to potentially high variances. Thus, the information that supports forest management planning and decision making will shift from being deterministic to being stochastic in nature. One adaptation option available to forest managers is to develop decision support tools that account for randomness in variables used in planning and decision making. This will require the adoption of risk management approaches and the development of methods of analysis that explicitly incorporate random and stochastic variables and risk preferences of individual decision makers. The remainder of this chapter describes concepts and some general modeling tools and approaches that forest managers can use to evaluate and adjust for risk in forest management decision making.

Complete Chapter List

Search this Book: