×
Receive a 20% Discount on All Purchases Directly Through IGI Global's Online Bookstore
Shopping Cart
Login
Register
Language:
English
All Products
All Products
Books
Journals
Videos
Book Chapters
Journal Articles
Video Lessons
Teaching Cases
Special Offers
Create a Free IGI Global Library Account to Receive a 25% Discount on All Purchases
Exclusive benefits include one-click shopping, flexible payment options, free COUNTER 4 and MARC records, and a 25% discount on all titles as well as the award-winning InfoSci
®
-Databases.
Sign Up Now!
InfoSci
®
-Journals Annual Subscription Price for New Customers: As Low As US$ 4,950
This collection of over 175 e-journals offers unlimited access to highly-cited, forward-thinking content in full-text PDF and XML with no DRM. There are no platform or maintenance fees and a guarantee of no more than 5% increase annually.
Learn More
Discounted Titles Only Available through IGI Global’s Online Bookstore
Take 20% off all publications purchased directly through the IGI Global Online Bookstore.
Shop Now
Encyclopedia of Information Science and Technology, Fourth Edition (10 Volumes) Extended Offer
Receive the complimentary e-books for the first, second, and third editions with the purchase of the Encyclopedia of Information Science and Technology, Fourth Edition e-book. Plus, take 20% off when purchasing directly through IGI Global's Online Bookstore.
Purchase
Books
Journals
InfoSci
®
-Databases
Videos
OnDemand
Publish
with IGI Global
Resources
Librarians
InfoSci
®
-Databases
Book Title List
Journal Title List
Video Title List
Consortia Partnerships
Library and Publisher Collaborations
Product Distributors
Catalogs
Library Account Program
Instructors
Course Adoption
Teaching Cases
Researchers
Browse Books
Browse Journals
Streaming Videos
OnDemand Downloads
Webinars
Authors and Editors
eEditorial Discovery
®
System
Peer Review Process
Ethics and Malpractice
Fair Use Policy
Copy Editing Service
FAQ
Distributors
Distributor Resources
Book Distributors
Journal Subscription Agencies
E-Resource Partners
About Us
Newsroom
news
room
Search
Search:
All Posts
IGI Global News
New Title Releases
Press Releases
All Tags
Accounting & Finance (19)
Adaptive & Complex Systems (7)
Adult Learning (17)
Aerospace Engineering (9)
Agent Technologies (4)
Algorithms (3)
Applied E-Learning (35)
Articles (143)
Artificial Intelligence (45)
Asia (73)
Author News (449)
Awards & Recognition (88)
Bioinformatics (12)
Biologically-Inspired Computing (10)
Biomedical Technologies (19)
Biometrics (9)
Blended & Mobile Learning (24)
Book Series (234)
Books & E-Books (725)
Business & Organizational Research (40)
Business & Technical Education (13)
Business and Management (204)
Business Information Systems (33)
Business Intelligence (21)
Business Process Management (20)
Chapters (198)
Chemical Engineering (4)
Chemoinformatics (3)
China (50)
Clinical Technologies (15)
Cognitive Informatics (21)
Cognitive Learning (8)
Collective Intelligence (7)
Computational Intelligence (12)
Computational Linguistics (6)
Computer Engineering (9)
Computer Graphics & Art (4)
Computer Science and Information Technology (177)
Computer Simulation (3)
Computer Vision & Image Processing (5)
Computer-Assisted Language Learning (3)
Computer-Mediated-Communication (9)
Conferences (171)
Consumer Management (6)
Course Adoption (85)
Cyber Behavior (32)
Cyber Warfare & Terrorism (30)
Cybernetics (8)
Data Analysis & Statistics (10)
Data Mining (27)
Data Warehousing (13)
Database Technologies (88)
Databases (32)
Decision Support Systems (9)
Digital Crime & Forensics (17)
Digital Divide & Developing Countries (21)
Digital Libraries (21)
Digital Literacy (17)
Distance Education (26)
E-Business (26)
E-Collaboration (18)
E-Commerce (16)
Eastern Europe (59)
Education (304)
Electrical Engineering (4)
Electronic Services (14)
End User Computing (4)
Engineering (76)
Engineering Education (14)
Enterprise Information Systems (8)
Enterprise Resource Planning (2)
Entrepreneurship & E-Innovation (5)
Environmental Engineering (24)
Environmental, Agricultural, and Physical Sciences (73)
Europe (137)
Events & Collaborations (265)
Facebook (10)
Free Content (122)
Gaming (36)
Gender & Technology (11)
Geoinformatics (6)
Global Business (36)
Global Information Technology (39)
Government and Law (107)
Grid & High Performance Computing (1)
Healthcare (102)
Healthcare Information Systems (45)
Hospitality, Travel & Tourism Management (7)
Human Aspects of Business (30)
Human Aspects of Technology (95)
Human Resources Development (19)
India (46)
Industrial Engineering (4)
Industrial Informatics (4)
Information Ethics (12)
Information Resources Management (21)
Information Retrieval (9)
Information Security & Privacy (28)
Information Trust (17)
Information Value & Quality (6)
InfoSci-Books (172)
InfoSci-Cases (15)
InfoSci-Databases (60)
InfoSci-Dictionary (4)
InfoSci-Disciplines (7)
InfoSci-Journals (133)
InfoSci-Medical (7)
InfoSci-OnDemand (15)
InfoSci-Select (1)
InfoSci-Videos (12)
Instructional Design (24)
Interactive Technologies (30)
Internet Technologies (27)
Interview (102)
IT Governance (10)
IT Policy & Standardization (9)
IT Research & Theory (11)
Journals (280)
Knowledge Discovery (63)
Knowledge Management (103)
Knowledge Society (48)
Latin & South America (19)
Library and Information Science (142)
Library Information Systems (94)
Library Technology Innovation Series (13)
Marketing (33)
Materials Science (1)
Mechanical Engineering (4)
Media and Communications (147)
Medical, Healthcare, and Life Sciences (122)
Middle East & Africa (68)
Mobile Computing (24)
Multimedia Technology (35)
Music Technologies (1)
Nanotechnology (7)
Networking (39)
Neural Networks (6)
Newsletter (133)
North America (363)
Oceania (57)
Online Symposium (37)
Open Source Software (5)
Partnerships (15)
Presentations (68)
Public & Sector Management (18)
Public Policy & Administration (100)
Research Essentials (22)
Research Trends (38)
Resources for Distributors (272)
Resources for Instructors (400)
Resources for Librarians (374)
Resources for Researchers (436)
Resources for Translators (119)
Reviews & Indexing (84)
Robotics (15)
Security and Forensics (112)
Semantic Web (2)
Small & Medium Enterprises (2)
Social Computing (57)
Social Sciences and Humanities (153)
Software (96)
Strategic Information Systems (3)
Supply Chain Management (7)
Surveys, Measurements & Response Systems (6)
Sustainable Development (28)
Systems & Software Engineering (2)
Teaching Cases (61)
Technologies in Higher Education (38)
Technologies in K-12 Education (27)
Telecommunications (3)
Topic Collections (29)
Twitter (13)
Ubiquitous & Pervasive Computing (3)
Urban & Regional Development (8)
Videos (14)
Virtual Communities (43)
Virtual Learning Environments (61)
Web Services (7)
Web Technologies & Engineering (11)
Web-Based Teaching & Learning (37)
Wireless Systems (9)
Posted any time
Posted this week
Posted this month
Posted this year
Sort by:
Relevance
Newest first
Oldest first
Reset
Search
Dr. Sergio Canavero plans to attempt the first human head transplant this December
Dr. Sergio Canavero and his Upcoming Procedure: Ethical? Egregious? Enigmatic? Your Call
By
Colby Conway
on
May 8, 2017
Email Updates
RSS
In highly controversial fashion, Sergio Canavero, an Italian neurosurgeon, has plans for a late 2017 surgical procedure that he believes will result in one of the largest advances in the medical field to date. However, other doctors in the field are of the opinion that the procedure should not happen. Canavero and Chinese surgeon Xiaping Ren have plans to perform the first human head transplant, reportedly scheduled for December of 2017. This procedure, which seems straight out of a sci-fi horror film, has created such controversy that not only the medical profession, but society as a whole has debated this operation on numerous grounds. The ethical considerations revolving around this procedure play a large role to say the least, while the physical risks of the operation are perilous.
One of the last holdups for the surgery is the lack of a volunteer. Valery Spiridonov, a man in his early-30s who has Werdnig-Hoffmann disease (a genetic disease that deteriorates and kills motor neurons) originally volunteered his head for the surgery. However, recent reports indicate that Spiridonov will not be a patient in this procedure. Whomever the patient in the surgery turns out to be, Canavero will proceed ahead with his blueprints for the procedure.
From a medical standpoint, the surgery is far from simple. There will be two teams in the operating room, with rumors of over 100 surgeons in on the procedure. The body of the brain-dead man, assuming family’s permission, would be prepped for surgical decapitation, while another team of surgeons would fill Spridonov’s—or whoever the patient is—veins full of fluids at 50 degrees Fahrenheit in order to delay the death of brain tissue. The surgeons have one hour to make this happen. They would then make a quick, precise cut on both bodies, just above the collarbone, and be sure to prevent nerve damage and scarring. When it becomes time to attach the head, and making sure that the brain and spinal cord can fuse together properly, Canavero and his team will use polyethylene glycol, or PEG, to combine two of the most intricate parts of the human body. The patient will remain in an induced coma for a few weeks following the surgery, since machines will perform many of the basic life functions, including breathing and pumping blood. For a more detailed description of the surgery, check out this
video
.
With all that in mind, Canavero claimed that the procedure has a “90 percent plus” chance of success. To put that into perspective, one of the world’s most extensive face transplants carries just a 50 percent chance of survival. Surgeries for carpal tunnel and detached retinas carry a success rate right around 90 percent, a similar mark proclaimed by Canavero for the first human head transplant.
Ashok Kumar Biswas
, geriatric public health specialist and editor-in-chief of IGI Global’s
International Journal of User-Driven Healthcare (IJUDH)
, weighed in on the procedure, which he believes to be a “media stunt,” as well as the “illogical” success rate claim by Canavero.
“Unless you perform it, you must not guess about the chances in such a highly risky surgical procedure,” says Biswas. “Performing on a rat, dog or even a rhesus monkey doesn’t give you a success rate on a human.”
A major concern in the surgery is whether the body will accept the new head. In the first hand transplant, the recipient later had the hand removed. Biswas questions whether the patient can accept a new body mentally, let alone physically. Canavero has stated that the patient will have to take immunosuppressants, likely every day, to ensure that the body does not reject the head and start internally attacking it. Would that allow the body to survive from pathogens? Not without a daily dose of immunosuppressants, and even then there is no guarantee.
While the sheer scientific details of the surgery have been questioned, perhaps it’s the ethical quandaries revolving around this procedure that has society scratching its head. Are Canavero’s motives for scientific advancement or the pure lust of becoming a medical pioneer?
Brett Lunceford
, published author and contributor to multiple IGI publications, including the
International Journal of Technoethics
(IJT), points out that “pushing the envelope” of what can be done carries great risk.
“If you are the outlier and many others in the profession think that this is bad science and unethical, then you have to be willing to accept the possibility that you are a crackpot rather than a visionary,” says Lunceford.
Aside from the surgeon’s motives, the costs of this surgery have some questioning whether the benefits are worthwhile. Would this money be better suited for spinal cord research? What if there was a way to fix the spinal cord to allow the individual to regain movement, without having to transfer the head to a new body? These are just a few more ethical lines the procedure tiptoes.
“First of all, it proves to be insane when it comes to the cost, which I feel is unnecessary,” says Biswas.
“I realize that most people would consider their life priceless, but the estimates I have seen for this procedure puts it in the tens of millions of dollars,” says Lunceford. “Is this something that would only benefit the very wealthy?”
“Most importantly, where is the benefit of this expensive and insane procedure?” questions Biswas. “We are human with intelligence to improve, I agree! However, we should invest our resources in better reason of survival. The donor body with valuable, useful organs can give lives to many.”
Lunceford agrees with Biswas, explaining, "To use an entire body means that this body will only help one person, where harvesting the liver, kidneys, heart, and other tissues could help many more people, who may need these organs to survive."
To this point in his career, much of Lunceford’s work has come from studying embodiment and identity, which has become monumental in this case. After the surgery, if it proves successful, Spiridonov, or whomever the patient is, will look in the mirror and see a different body than the one with which they were born. What does that mean for an individual’s identity? What does that do to a person’s sense of self?
“So much of our embodied experience is tied to elements of the body that we don’t even think about,” says Lunceford. “Imagine looking in the mirror and not seeing your own face.”
Rocci Luppicini
, associate professor at the University of Ottawa and editor-in-chief of IGI Global’s
International Journal of Technoethics (IJT)
analyzes three different meaning of “the body” and how it relates to an individual’s sense of self.
“The continuity of one concept of self derives much of its meaning from one human body they were born and develop with,” says Luppicini. “If you take that away, you remove some of what constitutes our self-concept and gives meaning to our individual lives.”
Another question about the surgery asks who is the donor and who is the recipient? Who donates and who receives? Additionally, what receives and what donates? Is the body of the brain-dead individual receiving or donating life? Is the head of the individual gaining a new body, and life, or receiving the body of an individual to carry out his life? According to Luppicini, it’s a “complicated” question that has many questions itself.
“What is being exchanged (arm, leg, face, head), at what stage in life (newborn, child, adolescent, adult), for what aim (survival, normalization, augmentation), within what type of community, with what values and ethical/religious norms in place, etc.,” says Luppicini. “Second, we need legal framework in place to safeguard the rights and responsibilities of implicated agents (donor-recipients-family members—community members) affected by such an act. And third, there is a need of a proper technoethical inquiry to examine the technical and non-technical aspects of such a relationship to determine if it is worth it."
As this procedure looms closer, the advocates and adversaries will continue to make their assertions regarding the first human head transplant. Does the head transplant cross an ethical line? Or many? Are the surgeons’ motives for the right reasons? Does the overwhelming amount of media hype distract individuals from bold assertions, some without much backing, made by Canavero?
Luppicini addresses these concerns, saying “What I have seen so far lacks and I would invite proponents of this procedure, like Canavero, to participate in the dialogue, since the agenda focus seems to revolve around misinformation, untested promises, and media hype to get the public interested in this experiment.”
From a utilitarian perspective, does this operation satisfy “the greatest happiness for the greatest number of people?” Lunceford points out that “consequentialists would say that the ethics depend on the outcome of the procedure.” With all of the ethical dilemmas swirling pre-operation, will society and medical professionals be inclined to wait until post-op to come to its conclusions? Is putting a living patient’s life in danger worth it when the first imperative in the medical field is to “do no harm?” Biswas finds it “morally insensible.”
So, does the procedure cross an ethical boundary for three IGI Global editors-in-chief? It sure does.
Lunceford
: “For me, the main issues are: Are we ready, and is it worth it to lose these organs in this procedure? I would like to see more research on spinal cord repair before we do this, and the medical professionals who do this kind of research are not convinced that we are ready."
Luppicini
: “While I commend [Sergio] Canavero and others with his keen scientific mind for their efforts, I do not think it is ethically worthwhile at this time to misinform the public about the real risks about transplants in general or mislead potential (and often desperate) participants to sign up to be guinea pigs for unknown suffering, prior to approved testing on a primate level."
Biswas
: “Altogether, I am completely against this decision, and my moral conscience would never accept such illogical action in the future either. After all, I too am a human, not a robotic science maniac.”
A sincere thanks to Dr. Brett Lunceford, Dr. Rocci Luppicini and Dr. Ashok Kumar Biswas for sharing their thoughts on the ethical considerations regarding the first human head transplant. Please take a moment to view the
International Journal of Technoethics
and
International Journal of User-Driven Healthcare
.
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not reflect the views of IGI Global.
Newsroom Contact:
Elizabeth Leber
Promotions Assistant
eleber@igi-global.com
(717) 533-8845, ext. 132
www.igi-global.com
Browse for more posts in:
Medical, Healthcare, and Life Sciences
Biomedical Technologies
Clinical Technologies
No comments
Comments
Log in
or
sign up
to comment.
Be the first to comment!