Evidence of Compensatory Adaptation to Unnatural Media in a Field Study of Process Redesign Dyads

Evidence of Compensatory Adaptation to Unnatural Media in a Field Study of Process Redesign Dyads

Ned Kock (Texas A&M International University, USA)
Copyright: © 2007 |Pages: 34
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-59904-286-2.ch006
OnDemand PDF Download:


Much of the past research on electronic communication media suggests that those media pose obstacles to communication in collaborative tasks when compared with the face-to-face medium. On the other hand, past research also points at mixed findings in connection with the quality of the outcomes of collaborative tasks, generally suggesting that the use of electronic communication media has no negative effect on those outcomes. A new theoretical framework building on human evolution theory, called compensatory adaptation theory, has been proposed to explain these contradictory findings. This study provides a review and test of compensatory adaptation theory. It investigates the impact of the use of an electronic communication medium on 20 business process redesign dyads involving managers and professionals at a large defense contractor, with a focus on cognitive effort, communication ambiguity, message preparation, fluency, and task outcome quality. The study suggests that even though the use of electronic communication media seemed to increase cognitive effort and communication ambiguity, it had a neutral impact on task outcome quality. These results appear to be an outcome of compensatory adaptation, whereby the members of the dyads interacting through the electronic communication medium modified their behavior in order to compensate for the obstacles posed by the medium, which is suggested by a decrease in fluency and an increase in message preparation. The results generally support predictions based on compensatory adaptation theory.

Complete Chapter List

Search this Book:
Table of Contents
Mehdi Khosrow-Pour
Chapter 1
Tanya Bondarouk, Klaas Sikkel
The starting point of this chapter is the belief that it is neither the quality of the technology, nor that of the individual users, but the... Sample PDF
The Relevance of Learning Processes for IT Implementation
Chapter 2
Ronald Dattero, Stuart D. Galup, Jing “Jim” Quan
In this chapter, we quantify the differences in the hourly salaries of female software developers with their male counterparts using the human... Sample PDF
Salary Differences Between Male and Female Software Developers
Chapter 3
Neil F. Doherty, Heather Fulford
Ensuring the security of corporate information assets has become an extremely complex, challenging and high-priority activity, due partly to their... Sample PDF
Exploring the Effectiveness of Information Security Policies
Chapter 4
Deirdre A. Folkers
Higher education has traditionally been very slow moving, with change being measured in years or even decades. Recently, external forces have... Sample PDF
Competing in the Marketplace: Incorporating Online Education into Higher Education
Chapter 5
Omar E.M. Khalil, Manal M. Elkordy
This chapter reports on the findings of research investigating the influence of information quality on EIS information use as well as the possible... Sample PDF
Determinant of Information Quality and Use of Executive Information Systems (EIS) in UK
Chapter 6
Ned Kock
Much of the past research on electronic communication media suggests that those media pose obstacles to communication in collaborative tasks when... Sample PDF
Evidence of Compensatory Adaptation to Unnatural Media in a Field Study of Process Redesign Dyads
Chapter 7
Laura Lally
This chapter draws upon normal accident theory and the theory of high reliability organizations to examine the potential impacts of information... Sample PDF
Information Technology as a Target, Shield, and Weapon in the Post-9/11 Environment
Chapter 8
D. Harrison McKnight, Norman L. Chervany
This study examines a model of factors influencing system troubleshooter trust in their supervisors, contrasting experiential and nonexperiential... Sample PDF
An Extended Trust Building Model: Comparing Experiential and Non-Experiential Factors
Chapter 9
Souren Paul, Carol Stoak Saunders, William David Haseman
Information acquisition and its use are frequently considered critical to the decision- making process, yet related research, especially about the... Sample PDF
A Question of Timing: Information Acquisition and Group Decision Making Performance
Chapter 10
Alan R. Peslak
Privacy on the Internet has been of increasing concern with the explosive growth of electronic commerce. A series of past surveys by the Federal... Sample PDF
Progress in Internet Privacy Policies: A Review of Survey of U.S. Companies from 1998 through 2006
Chapter 11
Margi Levy, Philip Powell, Les Worrall
Small firms’ use of e-business is limited and little is known about what drives them to embrace e-business. Using survey data from 354 small and... Sample PDF
The Relationship of Strategic Intent to the Enablers and Inhibitors of E-Business Adoption in SMEs
Chapter 12
Monideepa Tarafdar, Jie (Jennifer) Zhang
Web site usability is concerned with how easy and intuitive it is for individuals to presence, as perceived by users. The usability of Web sites is... Sample PDF
Understanding Web Site Usability: The Influence of Web Site Design Parameters
Chapter 13
Abhishek Nirjar, Andrew Tylecote
Small and medium enterprises in the Indian software development industry, like their larger counterparts, are mostly low on the value ladder. This... Sample PDF
Breaking Out of Lock-In: Insights from Case Studies into Ways to Up the Value Ladder for Indian Software SMEs
Chapter 14
Tor Guimaraes
Agent technology offers a new means of effectively managing knowledge and addresses complex decision processes which heretofore appeared... Sample PDF
Comparing Expert Systems and Agent Technology for KM
About the Editor
About the Authors