Student Perceptions and Adoption of University Smart Card Systems

Student Perceptions and Adoption of University Smart Card Systems

Jamie Murphy (University of Western Australia, Australia), Richard Lee (University of South Australia, Australia) and Evan Swinger (University of Western Australia, Australia)
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-4666-1954-8.ch011
OnDemand PDF Download:


This study investigated student adoption of university campus card (UCC) applications. A review of smart card, technology adoption and Unified Theory of Acceptance and Use of Technology (UTAUT) literature led to three focus groups and a survey of student perceptions and attitudes towards the university’s campus card. Perceptions of 17 UCC components differed significantly across four student variables – international versus domestic, willingness to load funds, gender, and university level – supporting and extending UTAUT. Willingness to load funds on their UCC differed significantly across 16 out of 17 components, followed by domestic versus overseas students differing on 14 components, university level differing on 13 components and gender on 10. Overall, students reported that extra UCC features would enhance the university’s image, improve their student experience, and encourage them to use UCCs. The results and managerial implications can help universities select and prioritise UCC functions for campus adoption and implementation.
Chapter Preview


Smart cards exemplify an intermediating technology, which requires a critical mass of adopting groups for the technology to succeed (Plouffe, Vandenbosch, & Hulland, 2001). Electronic customer relationship systems, for example, need adoption by both individuals and organisations (Jones, 2009; Wu & Wu, 2005). In a tertiary environment, successful smart card applications depend on students as individual adopters and organisational adoption by the university and campus merchants such as cafeterias, vending machines and bookshops. Successful implementation of smart cards requires acceptance by all these parties, particularly the end users. As such, this study focuses on University Campus Card (UCC) adoption at the individual level, by students.

About the size and shape of a credit card, UCCs integrate well into student life on campus (Rochet & Tirole, 2003). A dynamic platform rather than a plastic card, the applications on a UCC may depend on university funding and usually require widespread acceptance by students, merchants and the university. Among other things, these smart cards can incorporate student photos, authenticate memberships or building access, facilitate library borrowing, store homework and pay for purchases such as photocopying, food and drink.

In part due to UCCs’ rapidly evolving and growing role in student experiences, there seems little research of smart cards in tertiary education. Yet as UCC technology evolves, universities grapple with issues such as what smart card applications to implement, encouraging student use and successful UCC implementation across myriad departments and organisations. Universities also need to identify and prioritise UCC functions that improve student experiences, university investments and merchant relationships. Business such as bookshops, cafeterias, bank ATM machines and vending machines are woven into the campus tapestry. Finally, universities must gauge external partnerships. Collaborating with public transport, for example, would add a UCC function and reduce the need for a card.

To help address the questions above, this paper draws upon technology adoption literature and an Australian university’s UCC challenges. Unlike adoption research that assumes a single adopting group (Plouffe et al., 2001; Wu & Wu, 2005), this paper treats UCCs as an intermediating technology with three adopting groups − merchants, students and the university. The Unified Theory of Acceptance and Use of Technology (UTAUT) (Venkatesh, Morris, Davis, & Davis, 2003) helps frame two qualitative and one quantitative investigation of student UCC adoption. As individual differences, such as gender, relate to technology acceptance (Sun & Zhang, 2006; Wu & Wu, 2005), this study investigated how four variables – gender, university level, willingness to load fund, and student status – relate to student attitudes towards and use of UCCs.

Besides applying and extending UTAUT to campus cards, the study helps university administrators understand short to medium term implications of UCC systems, including key drivers for increasing UCC use. Understanding these drivers would help universities plan and manage their ongoing UCC investment decisions.

This study starts with a review of smart card technology and its applications in tertiary institutions. Next, technology acceptance literature and the results of two exploratory focus groups lead to a modified UTAUT model and subsequent quantitative survey. After highlighting the quantitative results, the paper concludes with implications, limitations and future research.

Complete Chapter List

Search this Book:
Editorial Advisory Board
Table of Contents
Anabela Mesquita
Chapter 1
Osemeke Mosindi, Petia Sice
Recent trends in researching Information Behaviour in organisations show that the initial focus on technology has shifted to cognitive methods that... Sample PDF
An Exploratory Theoretical Framework for Understanding Information Behaviour
Chapter 2
Damian O. Eke
In the past few decades, there has been a lineal relationship between technology and development- the belief that availability of technology would... Sample PDF
ICT Integration in Nigeria: The Socio-Cultural Constraints
Chapter 3
Linwu Gu, Milam Aiken, Jianfeng Wang, Kustim Wibowo
Previous studies have explored privacy instruments and disclosures as factors that affect on-line shopping intentions or attitudes. However, few... Sample PDF
The Influence of Information Control upon On-Line Shopping Behavior
Chapter 4
Jia Shen, Lauren B. Eder
Social commerce is the latest development in e-commerce to combine the power of online social networking with shopping. While the adoption of... Sample PDF
An Examination of Factors Associated with User Acceptance of Social Shopping Websites
Chapter 5
Andrew McDonald, Sven Helmer
Information Systems (IS) Project Management (PM) is fundamental to the modern, constantly changing and upgrading business world and is impacted by... Sample PDF
A Comparative Case Study of Indonesian and UK Organisational Culture Differences in IS Project Management
Chapter 6
Swadesh Kumar Samanta, John Woods, Mohammed Ghanbari
In this paper, the authors demonstrate that language diversity imposes a significant barrier in message communication like Short Messaging Service... Sample PDF
Automatic Language Translation: An Enhancement to the Mobile Messaging Services
Chapter 7
Gareth Peevers, Gary Douglas, Mervyn A. Jack, Diarmid Marshall
In this paper, the authors compare the usability of SMS mobile banking and automated IVR telephone banking. Participants (N = 116) used SMS banking... Sample PDF
A Usability Comparison of SMS and IVR as Digital Banking Channels
Chapter 8
Gareth Peevers, Gary Douglas, Mervyn A. Jack
Participants (N=71) took part in mortgage interviews with a human agent interacting with a computer using four different communication modes: a... Sample PDF
Multimedia Technology in the Financial Services Sector: Customer Satisfaction with Alternatives to Face-to-Face Interaction in Mortgage Sales
Chapter 9
Abram L. J. Walton, Sharon A. DeVaney, Darrel L. Sandall
This qualitative study used grounded theory to examine how university graduate students felt about closed circuit television (CCTV) as it relates to... Sample PDF
Graduate Students’ Perceptions of Privacy and Closed Circuit Television Systems in Public Settings
Chapter 10
Yann Truong
Through a questionnaire survey, this study identifies and investigates seven antecedents of consumer acceptance of mobile TV advertising. Negative... Sample PDF
Antecedents of Consumer Acceptance of Mobile Television Advertising
Chapter 11
Jamie Murphy, Richard Lee, Evan Swinger
This study investigated student adoption of university campus card (UCC) applications. A review of smart card, technology adoption and Unified... Sample PDF
Student Perceptions and Adoption of University Smart Card Systems
Chapter 12
Mats Edenius, Hans Rämö
In this paper, the authors examine how senior managers, as professional workers, in a leading ICT company use smartphones, according to new... Sample PDF
An Office on the Go: Professional Workers, Smartphones and the Return of Place
Chapter 13
Christine Sarah Fidler, Raed Kareem Kanaan, Simon Rogerson
This paper identifies and highlights the significance of Wasta as a barrier to e-government implementation within The Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan... Sample PDF
Barriers to e-Government Implementation in Jordan: The Role of Wasta
Chapter 14
Zaid I. Al-Shqairat, Ikhlas I. Altarawneh
The Initiative of establishing Information Technology (IT) and Community Service Centers, later renamed Knowledge Stations (KSs) was launched in... Sample PDF
The Role of Partnership in E-Government Readiness: The Knowledge Stations (KSs) Initiative in Jordan
Chapter 15
Stephanie Moser, Susanne Elisabeth Bruppacher, Frederic de Simoni
ICT advances will bring a new generation of ubiquitous applications, opening up new possibilities for the health sector. However, the social impacts... Sample PDF
Public Representation of Ubiquitous ICT Applications in the Outpatient Health Sector
Chapter 16
Nancy M. Chase, Becky Clegg
This exploratory study examines the impact of email as a primary communication technology upon the perceptions and work behaviors of higher... Sample PDF
Effects of Email Utilization on Higher Education Professionals
Chapter 17
Chia-Wen Tsai
Computing education in Taiwan is ineffective. Most teaching efforts in private vocational schools have been devoted to helping students pass tests... Sample PDF
How Much Can Computers and Internet Help?: A Long-Term Study of Web-Mediated Problem-Based Learning and Self-Regulated Learning
Chapter 18
Norazah Mohd Suki, T. Ramayah, Michelle Kow Pei Ming, Norbayah Mohd Suki
This paper explores the factors of enhancing employed job seekers intention to use social networking sites as a job search tool. 190 survey... Sample PDF
Factors Enhancing Employed Job Seekers Intentions to Use Social Networking Sites as a Job Search Tool
Chapter 19
Lars Göran Wallgren, Svante Leijon, Kerstin Malm Andersson
Little is known about managers’ perception of their subordinates’ motivation, especially how this perception influences managerial behavior. This... Sample PDF
IT Managers’ Narratives on Subordinates’ Motivation at Work: A Case Study
Chapter 20
Norazah Mohd Suki
The Internet is an incredible technology, offering users a vast choice of new songs and catalogue that can be browsed, streamed or bought online.... Sample PDF
Modelling Factors Influencing Early Adopters’ Purchase Intention Towards Online Music
About the Contributors