Crowdsourcing Education on the Web: A Role-based Analysis of Online Learning Communities

Crowdsourcing Education on the Web: A Role-based Analysis of Online Learning Communities

Joseph Corneli (The Open University, UK) and Alexander Mikroyannidis (The Open University, UK)
Copyright: © 2012 |Pages: 15
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-4666-0300-4.ch015
OnDemand PDF Download:


Learning online has significantly evolved over the past decade due to the emergence of Web 2.0 and 3.0 technologies that facilitate social learning in adaptive online environments. The open content movement and the associated techniques of crowdsourcing (i.e. assimilating several small contributions into resources of high quality) have further influenced education on the Web. This chapter investigates the concept of crowdsourcing in education through an analysis of case studies dealing with two open online learning communities, Peer 2 Peer University, and The case studies proceed via an analysis of the various roles played by the individuals involved in each organization. The outcomes of this analysis are used to extract general recommendations for building online communities and applying crowdsourcing techniques in educational contexts.
Chapter Preview


Web 2.0 and 3.0 technologies are transforming the landscape of learning. These technologies enable learners and pedagogues to co-produce learning environments that adapt to the competencies and motivations of each participant. Building these systems online, in the open, system developers and curriculum authors can make use of both high-intensity, high-cost contributions, and a long tail of smaller and less intensive contributions. This process of assimilating many small contributions into resources of high quality – colloquially known as crowdsourcing – is becoming a key aspect of the development of open online learning platforms. The challenge inherent to such efforts is to capture the surplus value of distributed processes of social engagement in a way that permits reuse and further development.

This chapter rethinks Nonaka and Takeuchi's well-known SECI model of knowledge creation (Nonaka & Takeuchi, 1995), and applies it to two case studies in crowdsourced education. The revisions to the SECI model are two-fold. First, what initially appears to be a simple and intuitive shorthand, obtained by mapping Nonaka and Takeuchi's Socialization/Externalization/Combination/Internalization onto Ken Wilber's I/We/Its/It (Wilber, 1997), upon further reflection leads us to a very different way of thinking about things. And, second, Nishida's philosophy of basho (summarized in English by Masao Abe (1988)), which was a noted inspiration for the SECI model, plays an even more central role in our version of the theory.

To put it somewhat colorfully, the “Golden Age” SECI is here updated to make it suitable to the analytical challenges present in our “Modern Age”. These challenges include organizations that make significant use of commons-based peer production (CBPP) (Benkler, 2005), organizations without a traditional management structure, and collaborations that cut across organizational boundaries. The focus in our analysis is on the various social roles taken on by the persons involved in such settings.

A point of departure for our new understanding of SECI is the critique found in Engeström's “Innovative learning in work teams: Analyzing cycles of knowledge creation in practice” (Engeström, 1999). Engeström makes a convincing case that “SECI” really doesn't adequately represent a cycle, despite the claims of its initial creators. The I/We/Its/It framework doesn't represent a cycle, either. Rather, we use Wilber's terms to describe a given social role in terms of its constituent actions. So for example, the role of “being a student” might be described as follows:

“I go to class, we do a class project, the objects of concern (“Its”) are things I can add to my portfolio or work-record; and fundamentally it is all about gaining a skill.”

This simple background story gives us a notion of role, persona, or identity: a role that is defined by its constituent actions, relative a given social context. And here, context is conceived of, after Nishida, as a “shared context in motion” (this is the meaning of the term “basho”).

Our little story describing the role of a student doesn't have much to do with “knowledge creation” or “epistemic action”. Still, now that we have a convenient way to talk about roles, we can move on to talk about how roles can change over time, how new roles come into existence, how different roles can conflict, and so on. It is in this respect that we recover the organizational learning dimensions of the SECI model – not as a byproduct of individual learning cycles, but as a complex of ongoing adjustments to the shared context and the social roles that are enacted therein (Engeström, 2007).

Thus, our concern is with the way a given context creates and is in turn created by its constituent social roles. Using this approach, we will develop a theory of organizational learning that is applicable to contemporary educational communities, possessing all of the complexities of our “Modern Age”.

Complete Chapter List

Search this Book:
Editorial Advisory Board
Table of Contents
Marshall S. Smith
David Wiley
Alexandra Okada, Teresa Connolly, Peter J. Scott
Chapter 1
Andy Lane
This chapter examines the role that open educational resources might play in widening participation in higher education. It begins by highlighting... Sample PDF
Widening Participation in Higher Education through Open Educational Resources
Chapter 2
Susan D’Antoni
This is the story of an international community convened to raise awareness of the growing Open Educational Resources (OER) movement. The experience... Sample PDF
The UNESCO OER Community 2005-2009: From Collective Interaction to Collaborative Action
Chapter 3
Lisa A. Petrides, Cynthia Jimes, Carol Hedgspeth
This work specifically sheds light on the ways that OER impacts teacher professional development, knowledge building, and interactive problem... Sample PDF
Knowledge Sharing and Collaboration as Indicators of Learning in OER Communities
Chapter 4
Giovanni Fulantelli, Davide Taibi, Manuel Gentile, Mario Allegra
The focus of this chapter is on “key issues for fostering OER communities of practice with teachers.” It is based on the successful experiences of... Sample PDF
Fostering OER Communities of Practice with Teachers
Chapter 5
Alexandra Okada, Scott Leslie
The aim of this chapter is to examine key factors for facilitating the development of reusable learning content (RLC) from the perspective of open... Sample PDF
Open Educators and Colearners as DJs: Reuse, Remix, and Recreate OER Collaboratively!
Chapter 6
Ivana Marenzi, Wolfgang Nejdl
In Content and Language Integrated Learning the context is to explicitly teach a subject through a foreign or second language, and therefore... Sample PDF
I Search Therefore I Learn - Active and Collaborative Learning in Language Teaching: Two Case Studies
Chapter 7
Freda Wolfenden, Alison Buckler
Much is written of the potential of Open Educational Resources (OERs) to contribute to improvements in the quality of and access to education... Sample PDF
Adapting OER for Professional Communities: The Teacher Education in Sub-Saharan Africa Experience
Chapter 8
Najat Smeda, Eva Dakich, Nalin Sharda
The purpose of this chapter is to present the vision of a framework for developing Web 2.0 tools for collaborative learning using digital... Sample PDF
Digital Storytelling with Web 2.0 Tools for Collaborative Learning
Chapter 9
Alexandra Bujokas de Siqueira, Danilo Rothberg, Martha Maria Prata-Linhares
This chapter presents lessons learnt after reflecting on a distance learning course based on Web 2.0 tools, which was promoted in order to teach... Sample PDF
Redrawing the Boundaries in Online Education through Media Literacy, OER, and Web 2.0: An Experience from Brazil
Chapter 10
Israel Gutiérrez Rojas, Raquel M. Crespo, Michael Totschnig, Derick Leony, Carlos Delgado Kloos
With the introduction of the Web 2.0 philosophy in the learning arena, the way learning actors interact has changed substantially. From a... Sample PDF
Managing Assessment Resources in the Open ICOPER Content Space
Chapter 11
Josh McCarthy
This study explores the efficacy of open educational resources and online social network sites in linking digital media students with industry... Sample PDF
Connected: Online Mentoring in Facebook for Final Year Digital Media Students
Chapter 12
Aileen McGuigan
Since 2006, the Teaching Qualification (Further Education) – a professional teaching qualification for in service college lecturers – has been... Sample PDF
Blogospheric Learning in a Continuing Professional Development Context
Chapter 13
Giselle Ferreira, Tina Wilson
The availability of Web 2.0 and open educational resources affords the emergence of novel learning spaces, but debate on these innovations has... Sample PDF
Open Educational Resources and Web 2.0 for Formal Learning in Information and Computer Sciences: A Case Study
Chapter 14
Sibren Fetter, Adriana J. Berlanga, Peter B. Sloep
Traditionally, the Open Educational Resources (OER) movement has focused on the production, distribution, and retrieval of open content. There is... Sample PDF
Peer-Support and Open Educational Resources
Chapter 15
Joseph Corneli, Alexander Mikroyannidis
Learning online has significantly evolved over the past decade due to the emergence of Web 2.0 and 3.0 technologies that facilitate social learning... Sample PDF
Crowdsourcing Education on the Web: A Role-based Analysis of Online Learning Communities
Chapter 16
Pradeep Kumar Misra
All over the world, governments, societies, and researchers are looking for ways to keep the ageing population active and engaged. The need of the... Sample PDF
Open Educational Resources: Lifelong Learning for Engaged Ageing
Chapter 17
Rebecca Ferguson, Simon Buckingham Shum
This chapter examines the meaning of “open” in terms of tools, resources, and education, and goes on to explore the association between open... Sample PDF
Towards a Social Learning Space for Open Educational Resources
Chapter 18
Martin Wolpers, Martin Memmel, Alberto Giretti, Miquel Casals, Katja Niemann, Marcus Specht
This chapter discusses the use of technology in supporting the study of architecture and design in Higher Education. Digital (often open)... Sample PDF
Supporting Collaborative Learning in the Architectural Domain
Chapter 19
Andy Lane, Andrew Law
Open Educational Resources comprise many types of assets, including rich media. However, dynamic rich media offer different opportunities and... Sample PDF
Collaborating over Rich Media: The Open University and BBC Partnership
Chapter 20
Christophe Salzmann, Denis Gillet, Francisco Esquembre, Héctor Vargas, José Sánchez, Sebastián Dormido
This chapter presents challenges in deploying remote and virtual laboratories as open educational resources with application to engineering... Sample PDF
Web 2.0 Open Remote and Virtual Laboratories in Engineering Education
Chapter 21
Teresa Connolly, Elpida Makriyannis
The Open Educational Resources (OER) community supports the belief that knowledge is a public good and, combined with technological advancement, can... Sample PDF
OERopoly: Collaborative Learning about Open Educational Resources through Game-Playing
About the Contributors