Perceptions of Mobile Device Website Design: Culture, Gender and Age Comparisons

Perceptions of Mobile Device Website Design: Culture, Gender and Age Comparisons

Dianne Cyr (Simon Fraser University, Canada), Milena Head (McMaster University, Canada) and Alex Ivanov (Simon Fraser University, Canada)
Copyright: © 2009 |Pages: 28
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60566-366-1.ch010
OnDemand PDF Download:


Anytime anywhere services offered through mobile commerce hold great potential to serve customers in wireless environments. However, there is limited understanding of how mobile Web site design is perceived by diverse users. This chapter explores how users who differ by culture, age, and gender perceive the design of a mobile device and their subsequent level of satisfaction with the device. Sixty subjects were tested in a controlled laboratory experiment on an Internet enabled phone. The results of a quantitative analysis were statistically inconclusive in terms of cultural and gender differences, but significant differences were found between older and younger users. However, an in-depth qualitative analysis of interview transcripts revealed some interesting differences among cultural, gender and age groups. Consistent with findings in the stationary Internet domain, design elements were found to impact satisfaction with mobile services.
Chapter Preview


Organisations will be well served to not be complacent with their wireless site design efforts… [But] before wireless site designers can address the usability challenge, and before organisations can leverage the commercial benefits of m-commerce, a deeper understanding of what aspects of usability is important to users and how they may differ in a wireless context is required. (Venkatesh et al., 2003, p.56)

Mobile commerce1 (or m-commerce) has huge potential to serve customers in wireless environments. The adoption of m-commerce is dependent on consumer acceptance of new and well-designed technologies (Ancker & D’Incau, 2002; Coursaris et al., 2003: Kim et al., 2002; Kumar & Zahn 2003; Nysveen et al., 2005; Perry et al., 2001; Schrott & Gluckler, 2004; Yang, 2005). It is expected design characteristics may influence user perceptions towards a mobile device. Congruent with work done by Cyr (2008), Information Design (ID), Navigation Design (ND), and Visual Design (VD) may all contribute to user adoption of a technology, as well as to satisfaction with a mobile technology.

Concerning user attitudes of handheld devices, it is also expected that diverse categories of users based on culture, gender, or age may react differently to using the device. There is growing literature on cross-cultural website design, mostly evaluated within the context of the stationary Internet (Becker, 2002; Chau et al., 2000; Cyr, 2008; Cyr et al., 2006; Cyr & Trevor-Smith, 2004; Marcus & Gould, 2000; Sun, 2001). More recently, research has examined culture and mobile data services (Choi et al., 2006). Investigations have likewise examined gender and design in the context of mobile devices, but research results are mixed (Anckar & D’Incau, 2002: Kwon & Chidambaram, 2000; Teo et al., 1999). Finally, research that examines cohorts by age (younger versus older users) is practically nonexistent when design is considered, although some studies have focused on special needs and preferences of older users (Goodman et al., 2005), or features of a mobile device perceived by user groups as adding value (Anckar & D’Incau 2002).

To explore the role of user differences concerning the perception of the design of a mobile device, users who differ on cultural, gender and age dimensions were tested on an Internet enabled cellular phone. Related to culture, Canadian and Chinese cultures were chosen due to acknowledged diversity (Hofstede, 1980). Between-group comparisons were conducted with respect to screen design (including information design, navigation design, and visual design), and satisfaction with the mobile device. In an exploration of these topics, the paper provides a review of relevant literature leading to the hypotheses for testing, the methodology used, an elaboration of results, and discussion of the findings. Given the increased diversity of mobile users, developing an expanded understanding of user perceptions and preferences not only has theoretical importance, but also serves to enhance the reengineering of devices to best meet consumer requirements.

Complete Chapter List

Search this Book:
Editorial Advisory Board
Table of Contents
Milena Head, Eldon Y. Li
Milena Head, Eldon Y. Li
Chapter 1
Jan H. Kietzmann
The recent evolution of mobile auto-identification technologies invites firms to connect to mobile work in altogether new ways. By strategically... Sample PDF
For Those About to Tag
Chapter 2
Adrian Lawrence, Jane Williams
As commercial interest in LBS increases, legal and regulatory bodies are becoming increasingly interested in the extent to which use of LBS may... Sample PDF
Privacy and Location-Based Mobile Services: Finding a Balance
Chapter 3
Dietmar G. Wiedemann, Wolfgang Palka, Key Pousttchi
A sizeable body of research on mobile payment evolved in recent years. Researchers analyzed success factors and acceptance criteria as well as... Sample PDF
Business Models for Mobile Payment Service Provision and Enabling
Chapter 4
Mikko Pynnonen, Jukka Hallikas, Petri Savolainen, Karri Mikkonen
In a digital home a so-called multi-play system integrates networked entertainment and communications systems. Using a mobile phone, all those... Sample PDF
Ubiquitous Communication: where is the Value Created in the Multi-Play Value Network?
Chapter 5
Adam Vrechopoulos, Michail Batikas
Mobile government transform many of the traditional governance practices. The citizens’ adoption of M-Government services (e.g. voting, tax... Sample PDF
Predicting the Adoption of Mobile Government Services
Chapter 6
Katarzyna Wac, Richard Bults, Bert-Jan van Beijnum, Hong Chen, Dimitri Konstantas
Mobile service providers (MoSPs) emerge, driven by the ubiquitous availability of mobile devices and wireless communication infrastructures. MoSPs’... Sample PDF
Towards Mobile Web 2.0-Based Business Methods: Collaborative QoS-Information Sharing for Mobile Service Users
Chapter 7
Giangluigi Me, Daniele Pirro, Roberto Sarrecchia
Currently the most popular attacks to the E-Banking Web applications target the authentication systems relying on the single-side client... Sample PDF
Strong Authentication for Financial Services: PTDs as a Compromise Between Security and Usability
Chapter 8
Antonio Ruiz-Martinez, Daniel Sanchez-Martinez, Maria Martinez-Montesinos, Antonio Gomez-Skarmeta
Non-repudiation is an important issue in mobile business and mobile commerce in order to provide the necessary evidences to prove whether some party... Sample PDF
Mobile Signature Solutions for Guaranteeing Non-Repudiation in Mobile Business and Mobile Commerce
Chapter 9
Soe-Tsyr Yuan, Fang-Yu Chen
Peer-to-Peer applications harness sharing between free resources (storage, contents, services, human presence, etc.). Most existing wireless P2P... Sample PDF
UbiSrvInt: A Context-Aware Fault-Tolerance Approach for WP2P Service Provision
Chapter 10
Dianne Cyr, Milena Head, Alex Ivanov
Anytime anywhere services offered through mobile commerce hold great potential to serve customers in wireless environments. However, there is... Sample PDF
Perceptions of Mobile Device Website Design: Culture, Gender and Age Comparisons
Chapter 11
Douglass J. Scott, Constantinos K. Coursaris, Yuuki Kato, Shogo Kato
This study compared the exchange of emotional content in PC and mobile e-mail in business-related discussions. Forty American business people were... Sample PDF
The Exchange of Emotional Content in Business Communications: A Comparison of PC and Mobile E-Mail Users
Chapter 12
Carla Ruiz-Mafe, Silvia Sanz-Blas, Adrian Broz-Lofiego, Daniel Marchuet
The chapter aims to present an in-depth study of the factors influencing Mobile Internet adoption. The authors analyse the influence of Internet use... Sample PDF
Mobile Internet Adoption by Spanish Consumers
Chapter 13
Mahil Carr
This chapter introduces concepts, frameworks and possible models for introducing mobile payments in India. The introductory section defines mobile... Sample PDF
Framework for Mobile Payment Systems in India
Chapter 14
E.S. Samundeeswari, F. Mary Magdalene Jane
Over the years computer systems have evolved from centralized monolithic computing devices supporting static applications, into client-server... Sample PDF
Mobile Code and Security Issues
Chapter 15
Tommi Pelkonen
This chapter describes the Finnish mobile telecommunications industry trends and prospects. In addition, it presents two theoretical frameworks... Sample PDF
Finland: Internationalization as the key to Growth and M-Commerce Success
Chapter 16
Dickson K.W. Chiu, S.C. Cheun, Ho-Fung Leung
In a service-oriented enterprise, the professional workforce such as salespersons and support staff tends to be mobile with the recent advances in... Sample PDF
Mobile Workforce Management in a Service-Oriented Enterprise: Capturing Concepts and Requirements in a Multi-Agent Infrastructure
Chapter 17
Dawn-Marie Turner, Sunil Hazari
Wireless technology has broad implications for the healthcare environment. Despite its promise, this new technology has raised questions about... Sample PDF
Bringing Secure Wireless Technology to the Bedside: A Case Study of Two Canadian Healthcare Organizations
About the Contributors